>> |
!p28NxRuKMo 04/04/10(Sun)21:30 No.8983524>>8983315
If you just want the actual helpful parts, why not just save as web page?
>>8983225
For me it's linguistics. Most of it SR actually does a good job of. Like, linguasofts for language teachers would go a long, long ways towards explaining the prevalence of Native languages that are in bad shape now, not to mention languages that don't exist yet, like Sperethiel. But a few things make me rage.
For instance, the bounty hunter in the core book's native language is listed as "Sioux". That's fucking great, is he a Nakota, Lakota, Dakota speaker, what? Cause they won't have an easy time understanding each other, let alone someone speaking something more distantly related, like Crow. Granted, they also have someone whose language is listed as Arabic in the core book, and that brings up the same issues. I think they have a damn broad idea of what a language is for intelligibility purposes.
And another: Where the fuck are all the Navajo speakers in Pueblo? Hopi and Zuni getting bigger I can accept, even if they're only at a thousand or so speakers each right now, because between the cultural revival and the linguasofts, a lot can get handwaved. But there are a hundred times that many Navajo speakers right now. Where the fuck did they all go? Even if the tribe's less politically powerful in Pueblo, they should have at least a fairly potent linguistic presence because of their stronger state now and the linguasoft/cultural revival angle.
Argh. Anyways, my point is, anybody's field is going to have points where Shadowrun doesn't agree with it, unless you're like, a pure mathematician or something. Maybe not even then. |