I didnt mind it, until it started getting a little weird. He literally made his save againts a Ghost's fear aura, running jumped above another character, then did a flaming,jumping kick againts the Ghost, and shouted "Lathander...KICK!".
I did. Everyone else was in to it, but you know, I cannot lay into the horror TOO thick, it's more of a subtle horror- "Eldritch Things beyond your understanding", kind of horror- a little Cthulu, and then a little Diablo.
But see, with his insane saves, I cannot FORCE him to fear the monsters, and he hasnt failed a single morale check.
He just takes it as him being 'The Glorious , Unbreakable Will of the Fist of Lathander's Sun!"
In game quote.