Posting mode: Reply
Password(Password used for file deletion)
  • Supported file types are: GIF, JPG, PNG
  • Maximum file size allowed is 3072 KB.
  • Images greater than 250x250 pixels will be thumbnailed.
  • Read the rules and FAQ before posting.
  • ????????? - ??

  • File : 1271166917.jpg-(185 KB, 800x800, assimilation_1___escape_by_damnengine.jpg)
    185 KB ITT: We make Magic cards using provided artwork v3.0 Anonymous 04/13/10(Tue)09:55 No.9165149  
    Post artwork (a few at a time, there's no rush and people need time to make cards). Make cards from the images, and post them. Critique and comment on other cards.

    Don't be a dick, and have fun!

    Oh, and here's a fairly good Magic card editor for beginners: http://magicseteditor.sourceforge.net/download
    >> Anonymous 04/13/10(Tue)10:00 No.9165200
         File1271167251.jpg-(45 KB, 375x523, Progeny Grove.jpg)
    45 KB
    heres one i made. needs feedback.
    >> Anonymous 04/13/10(Tue)10:03 No.9165222
    That is interesting.
    >> Anonymous 04/13/10(Tue)10:05 No.9165233
    i made a cycle of blink lands. can upload the rest if you wish.
    >> Anonymous 04/13/10(Tue)10:06 No.9165247

    Yes, please.
    >> Anonymous 04/13/10(Tue)10:08 No.9165257
         File1271167705.jpg-(40 KB, 375x523, Grotto Reef.jpg)
    40 KB
    >> Sommunist !CvgOA2wCo2 04/13/10(Tue)10:09 No.9165265
         File1271167753.jpg-(39 KB, 375x523, Magehunter card.jpg)
    39 KB
    Here's a couple I made last night. The thread reached the image limit before I posted them. I'm sure they're unbalanced and formatted wrong, but eh.

    >> Sommunist !CvgOA2wCo2 04/13/10(Tue)10:09 No.9165271
         File1271167785.jpg-(45 KB, 375x523, Nemo, Legendary Artificer.jpg)
    45 KB
    >> Anonymous 04/13/10(Tue)10:09 No.9165273
         File1271167799.jpg-(37 KB, 375x523, Hollowed Tree.jpg)
    37 KB
    yeah, theyre tribal. prolly wont stay that way. lemme know what you think of blink.
    >> Anonymous 04/13/10(Tue)10:10 No.9165283
         File1271167856.gif-(26 KB, 340x449, Morapp.gif)
    26 KB
    >> Anonymous 04/13/10(Tue)10:11 No.9165284
         File1271167861.jpg-(44 KB, 375x523, Volcanic Vent.jpg)
    44 KB
    >> Anonymous 04/13/10(Tue)10:12 No.9165292
         File1271167933.jpg-(46 KB, 375x523, War-Pride Memorial.jpg)
    46 KB
    this >>9165284 was 4/5

    >> Anonymous 04/13/10(Tue)10:21 No.9165309
    this thread died fairly quickly. the other one was pretty hoppin'. i think i kill threads...
    >> Anonymous 04/13/10(Tue)12:06 No.9166010
    dude i like that
    blink is a realy cool ability but i think it should just belong to certain groups of cards
    espeacialy for fairies its realy cool because they often have flash or sth.
    good job ;)
    ps: excuse my bad english
    >> Anonymous 04/13/10(Tue)12:34 No.9166378
    i made my first today but i dont know how to convert it to a jpg so i can post it
    help plz
    >> Anonymous 04/13/10(Tue)12:36 No.9166410
         File1271176619.jpg-(495 KB, 1843x3000, 1269318652774.jpg)
    495 KB
    >> Anonymous 04/13/10(Tue)12:40 No.9166446
         File1271176807.png-(28 KB, 500x500, mariowars.png)
    28 KB
    >> Anonymous 04/13/10(Tue)13:24 No.9167143
         File1271179445.jpg-(36 KB, 375x523, Arcbound Colossus.jpg)
    36 KB
    >> Anonymous 04/13/10(Tue)13:25 No.9167171
         File1271179526.jpg-(34 KB, 375x523, Gentle Leviathan.jpg)
    34 KB
    Didn't get to post this last thread...
    >> Anonymous 04/13/10(Tue)13:32 No.9167286
         File1271179957.jpg-(42 KB, 375x523, Hero's Sacrifice.jpg)
    42 KB
    >> Anonymous 04/13/10(Tue)13:34 No.9167312
         File1271180052.jpg-(34 KB, 375x523, Unreachable Heights.jpg)
    34 KB
    Couldn't post this either...
    >> Anonymous 04/13/10(Tue)13:38 No.9167376
         File1271180328.jpg-(516 KB, 2500x1200, c67917ce568fd44068720ddba294e7(...).jpg)
    516 KB
    >> Anonymous 04/13/10(Tue)13:39 No.9167393
         File1271180381.jpg-(43 KB, 500x572, diablo2.jpg)
    43 KB
    If it is Unreachable, then why do the creatures reach you?

    Not even mana should let them be able to do so.
    >> Anonymous 04/13/10(Tue)13:43 No.9167455
         File1271180608.jpg-(26 KB, 450x317, clockwork spider.jpg)
    26 KB
    Because then it would have to have a drawback
    >> Anonymous 04/13/10(Tue)13:52 No.9167607
    The unreachable turns out to be reachable.
    The nothing turns to everything.
    Magic balance is serious stuff.
    >> Anonymous 04/13/10(Tue)14:01 No.9167637
         File1271181697.jpg-(200 KB, 1567x671, 1204306765496.jpg)
    200 KB
    >> Anonymous 04/13/10(Tue)14:05 No.9167685
    Is that a picture of what happens when Dark Eldar rape Necron?
    >> Anonymous 04/13/10(Tue)14:05 No.9167695
    lern2hyperbole noob
    >> Anonymous 04/13/10(Tue)14:06 No.9167709
    oh look this thread again.
    >> Anonymous 04/13/10(Tue)14:12 No.9167783
         File1271182330.jpg-(43 KB, 375x523, Day's End.jpg)
    43 KB
    >> Anonymous 04/13/10(Tue)14:29 No.9167987
    oh wow, that is not insanely overpowered
    >> Anonymous 04/13/10(Tue)15:04 No.9168204
         File1271185475.jpg-(44 KB, 375x523, Grand Burial.jpg)
    44 KB
    >> Anonymous 04/13/10(Tue)15:09 No.9168297
         File1271185787.jpg-(44 KB, 375x523, Clockwork Spider.jpg)
    44 KB
    >> Anonymous 04/13/10(Tue)15:10 No.9168319
    would appreciate feedback on these two. balanced?
    >> Anonymous 04/13/10(Tue)15:12 No.9168344
         File1271185944.jpg-(56 KB, 600x433, 1266804312411.jpg)
    56 KB
    >> Anonymous 04/13/10(Tue)15:18 No.9168426
         File1271186295.jpg-(130 KB, 779x950, 1269477281135.jpg)
    130 KB
    Alright, then, let's see what happens.
    >> Anonymous 04/13/10(Tue)15:18 No.9168437
         File1271186317.jpg-(48 KB, 427x595, Adachi01.jpg)
    48 KB
    >> Anonymous 04/13/10(Tue)15:19 No.9168460
         File1271186384.jpg-(32 KB, 223x310, Image.ashx..jpg)
    32 KB
    Hard to tell. Maybe 6 mana is cheap for play and win/lose/draw. Compare with the pic(even though you have that damn Hexmage).
    Seem pretty balanced to me.
    >> Anonymous 04/13/10(Tue)15:24 No.9168547
         File1271186670.jpg-(75 KB, 455x306, 1269748946501.jpg)
    75 KB
    >> Anonymous 04/13/10(Tue)15:28 No.9168615
         File1271186890.jpg-(43 KB, 375x523, Corrupted Vanguard.jpg)
    43 KB
    >> Anonymous 04/13/10(Tue)15:28 No.9168616
         File1271186892.jpg-(247 KB, 1280x902, 1269811640423.jpg)
    247 KB
    >> Anonymous 04/13/10(Tue)15:28 No.9168619
         File1271186901.jpg-(44 KB, 375x523, Clockwork Spider.jpg)
    44 KB
    well, i would make it this way
    >> Anonymous 04/13/10(Tue)15:30 No.9168657
    seems needlessly complex
    >> Anonymous 04/13/10(Tue)15:31 No.9168664
         File1271187072.jpg-(43 KB, 373x524, Clockwork Spider.jpg)
    43 KB
    You're right. It's not. Just block it.
    >> Rules Guy !!YKiKvtlP4o5 04/13/10(Tue)15:35 No.9168737
    Each player sacrifices all permanents they control. Then, the player with the most cards in his or her graveyard wins.

    If two or more players are tied, the game is a draw.


    Actually, it's not. By turn 6, you can just put a 0/1 token in the thing's way consistently, and it will do jack-all nothing. If you can't block, you take 10. I might lower it to Frenzy 7 or 8, or maybe make it cost a bit more, but I wouldn't call it OP at all.
    >> Anonymous 04/13/10(Tue)15:36 No.9168749
         File1271187375.jpg-(45 KB, 375x523, Journey home.jpg)
    45 KB
    >> Rules Guy !!YKiKvtlP4o5 04/13/10(Tue)15:37 No.9168765
    That wouldn't do anything by itself. A creature that deals 0 damage is considered to have not dealt any damage, so it wouldn't trigger the Poisonous.
    >> Rules Guy !!YKiKvtlP4o5 04/13/10(Tue)15:38 No.9168796
    As an additional cost to cast CARDNAME, return a creature you control to it's owners hand.

    Search your library for a land card, reveal it, then put it into your hand. You gain 2 life.

    I'd say this would be better off either being an instant, as a combat trick, or only costing 3.
    >> Anonymous 04/13/10(Tue)15:41 No.9168838
         File1271187676.jpg-(45 KB, 375x523, Journey home 2.jpg)
    45 KB
    I reduced the cost and kept it as a sorcery. In terms of flavour, it wouldn't make sense to send a soldier home in the middle of a battle, so you should only do it in your own turn.
    >> Anonymous 04/13/10(Tue)15:42 No.9168857
         File1271187737.jpg-(360 KB, 884x1200, 1265677897111.jpg)
    360 KB
    >> Rules Guy !!YKiKvtlP4o5 04/13/10(Tue)15:45 No.9168920
    Fair enough, I thought that was what you were going for. But really, even though White rarely gets landsearching by itself, that was way overcosted at 4.
    >> Anonymous 04/13/10(Tue)15:46 No.9168942

    Cool card.
    >> Anonymous 04/13/10(Tue)15:47 No.9168961
         File1271188051.jpg-(49 KB, 375x523, Journeyman Dragon tamer.jpg)
    49 KB
    >> Anonymous 04/13/10(Tue)15:49 No.9169001
         File1271188194.jpg-(790 KB, 1600x1200, 1267805663759.jpg)
    790 KB
    Vlad as a Dragon Tamer. I could see it.
    >> Anonymous 04/13/10(Tue)15:55 No.9169099
         File1271188545.jpg-(51 KB, 375x523, Concubines.jpg)
    51 KB
    >> Rules Guy !!YKiKvtlP4o5 04/13/10(Tue)15:56 No.9169125
    Make sure you capitalize the name when you refer to it in the card.

    Journeyman Dragon Tamer

    When CARDNAME enters the battlefield, put a 1/1 red dragon creature token with flying onto the battlefield.

    3: Put a 1/1 red dragon creature token with flying onto the battlefield.

    I might make it so you have to tap him to do it, though.
    >> Anonymous 04/13/10(Tue)15:56 No.9169128
    not sure I got the wording right on that one. Rules guy, can you clear it up?
    >> Anonymous 04/13/10(Tue)15:57 No.9169139
         File1271188662.jpg-(123 KB, 800x600, 1265834933995.jpg)
    123 KB
    I'm starting to run out of arts, will have to start with fanarts...
    >> Anonymous 04/13/10(Tue)15:58 No.9169161
    The card is fine, except it shouldn't get you a dragon as it enters the battlefield.

    Should be a rare.
    >> Anonymous 04/13/10(Tue)15:59 No.9169165
    Proposital. You have poisonous 3 for 1 colorless. It could even cost 0 if you find it underpowered.
    >> Anonymous 04/13/10(Tue)15:59 No.9169171
         File1271188762.jpg-(50 KB, 375x523, Journeyman Dragon Tamer 2.jpg)
    50 KB
    >> Anonymous 04/13/10(Tue)15:59 No.9169173
         File1271188773.jpg-(238 KB, 1200x1080, 1270111547343.jpg)
    238 KB
    I'll post a few pictures. See what we get out of them.
    >> Rules Guy !!YKiKvtlP4o5 04/13/10(Tue)16:01 No.9169209
    Prevent all combat damage that would be dealt to CARDNAME.

    Whenever CARDNAME blocks, the blocked creature's controller discards a card.
    >> Rules Guy !!YKiKvtlP4o5 04/13/10(Tue)16:03 No.9169246
    The tap symbol is always the last thing before the colon on an activated ability, unless there's a phrase. SO it would be 3, Tap: not Tap, 3:

    Yes, I know, but I mean unless you have some way of pumping it, it's not all that good. You'd have to have a shitload of targeted pump, or global pump which wouldn't be online until turn 3 or 4, to make it win.
    >> Anonymous 04/13/10(Tue)16:05 No.9169284
         File1271189103.jpg-(188 KB, 725x1000, 1269733648336.jpg)
    188 KB
    >> PadawanNeckBeard 04/13/10(Tue)16:05 No.9169292
         File1271189115.jpg-(277 KB, 620x808, 1271115870999.jpg)
    277 KB
    I'm not a M:tG player, but I scour these threads for nice pictures. And that, I must say, is an exceptional picture. Thank you.

    Have a picture I saw earlier.
    >> Anonymous 04/13/10(Tue)16:05 No.9169296
         File1271189133.jpg-(49 KB, 375x523, Concubines 2.jpg)
    49 KB
    I tried typing it that way, but it wouldn't let me. It kept putting the tap symbol in front of the 3. *shrug*
    >> Anonymous 04/13/10(Tue)16:06 No.9169309
         File1271189165.jpg-(40 KB, 375x523, Mimiga Fishing Lake.jpg)
    40 KB
    >> Anonymous 04/13/10(Tue)16:06 No.9169324
         File1271189203.jpg-(112 KB, 800x626, 1243528656366.jpg)
    112 KB
    >> Anonymous 04/13/10(Tue)16:07 No.9169334
         File1271189245.jpg-(41 KB, 640x480, 1251316104905.jpg)
    41 KB
    >> Rules Guy !!YKiKvtlP4o5 04/13/10(Tue)16:09 No.9169373
    I've noticed that seems to be a trend with the Card maker. It makes you do it that way; how odd.

    I like it, but I'd try and give it a way to get more fish counters. Maybe invest some mana, and/or tap creatures to show that they've 'gone fishing'? I like the effect, but I'd like the ability to use it more than once if possible.
    >> Anonymous 04/13/10(Tue)16:10 No.9169378
         File1271189413.jpg-(412 KB, 1920x1200, 1270163870108.jpg)
    412 KB
    >> Anonymous 04/13/10(Tue)16:11 No.9169398
    Oh look. This thread again.
    >> Anonymous 04/13/10(Tue)16:11 No.9169408
         File1271189514.jpg-(44 KB, 375x523, Retaken by Nature.jpg)
    44 KB

    I'm new to this but here you go.
    >> Anonymous 04/13/10(Tue)16:12 No.9169422
         File1271189548.jpg-(238 KB, 1600x1089, rockonwatch.jpg)
    238 KB
    >> NorinTheWary !PhvIfIiVL2 04/13/10(Tue)16:12 No.9169425
    You need to put a comma in between costs. "3, T: Do a thing" should work.
    >> Anonymous 04/13/10(Tue)16:13 No.9169432
         File1271189585.jpg-(39 KB, 375x523, Multi-arm.jpg)
    39 KB
    >> Rules Guy !!YKiKvtlP4o5 04/13/10(Tue)16:13 No.9169439
    Enchantment - Aura

    Enchant Non-Basic Land

    Enchanted land is a forest.
    >> NorinTheWary !PhvIfIiVL2 04/13/10(Tue)16:14 No.9169451
    Should be an "Enchantment - Aura" with the ability "Enchant land". Also, nonbasic is one word. Also, capitalization.
    >> Rules Guy !!YKiKvtlP4o5 04/13/10(Tue)16:16 No.9169473
    Hm... maybe make it +1/+2 and double-strike. Battle Mastery costs 2W and gives just doublestrike, Holy Strength costs W and gives +1/+2, so I think that should be about fair for the mana cost.
    >> The Heavy 04/13/10(Tue)16:16 No.9169484
         File1271189811.jpg-(93 KB, 400x518, Abomination.jpg)
    93 KB
    Hooray, my favorite thread
    >> Anonymous 04/13/10(Tue)16:17 No.9169493
         File1271189834.jpg-(50 KB, 375x523, Journeyman Dragon Tamer 3.jpg)
    50 KB
    should be all good now.
    >> Rules Guy !!YKiKvtlP4o5 04/13/10(Tue)16:18 No.9169519
    WEll, the wording and all is fine. I think the power level is about right; you could 'abuse' it with blink effects, but there's much scarier stuff to blink in a red deck anyway.\

    I'd say it would be Enchant Nonbasic land, since it doesn't do shit to a basic land the way he has it.
    >> Anonymous 04/13/10(Tue)16:22 No.9169591
         File1271190161.jpg-(49 KB, 375x523, Chained Horror.jpg)
    49 KB
    >> Anonymous 04/13/10(Tue)16:23 No.9169606
         File1271190203.jpg-(151 KB, 373x450, 1265979230131.jpg)
    151 KB
    Let's get more creatures going, there's been a lot of lands and enchantments lately.
    >> Rules Guy !!YKiKvtlP4o5 04/13/10(Tue)16:25 No.9169641
    Capitalize Wizard, don't capitalize Sacrifice on the first ability.

    Chained Horror 3UUBB
    Creature - Horror
    As an additional cost to cast CARDNAME, sacrifice a Wizard.

    Tap, Sacrifice a Wizard: Counter target spell
    >> Anonymous 04/13/10(Tue)16:25 No.9169652
         File1271190345.jpg-(75 KB, 640x480, 1258437746314.jpg)
    75 KB
    Let's see what you make with porn, /tg/.
    >> Cidolfas Orlandu, aka Thunder God Cid !gYjELVKQn6 04/13/10(Tue)16:26 No.9169661
         File1271190380.jpg-(47 KB, 375x523, Draining Touch.jpg)
    47 KB
    >> Anonymous 04/13/10(Tue)16:26 No.9169666
         File1271190387.jpg-(30 KB, 375x523, Forest.jpg)
    30 KB
    Fear my originality.
    >> Anonymous 04/13/10(Tue)16:27 No.9169689
         File1271190458.jpg-(754 KB, 1200x1834, 1266060568452.jpg)
    754 KB

    Don't tempt me to dump Monster Hunter, dude. We'd be here for a week.
    >> Rules Guy !!YKiKvtlP4o5 04/13/10(Tue)16:27 No.9169690
    Hmmm... Yeah, nothing I can think of ruling-wise or wording-wise. Cost seems about right, since Douse in Gloom was 2B for only 2 damage and 2 life to a creature, and a hard-counter is 1UU. Having a choice between either for 4 seems just fine.
    >> Anonymous 04/13/10(Tue)16:28 No.9169714
         File1271190538.jpg-(44 KB, 375x523, Ancient Kraken.jpg)
    44 KB
    >> The Heavy 04/13/10(Tue)16:30 No.9169755
         File1271190632.jpg-(49 KB, 375x523, Fable Troops.jpg)
    49 KB

    Good, solid little common for control/drain decks.
    >> Cidolfas Orlandu, aka Thunder God Cid !gYjELVKQn6 04/13/10(Tue)16:31 No.9169775
         File1271190685.jpg-(39 KB, 375x523, Titanic Grove.jpg)
    39 KB
    >> Anonymous 04/13/10(Tue)16:32 No.9169801
         File1271190752.jpg-(47 KB, 375x523, Djinni of the Wish.jpg)
    47 KB
    >> The Heavy 04/13/10(Tue)16:32 No.9169803

    As it is, way too powerful, because you can essentially nullify your opponent's lands with him. I see what you're going for though, so I'd make his second ability "2U, T: Target land becomes an Island in addition to its other land types. (This effect is permanent.)"
    >> Cidolfas Orlandu, aka Thunder God Cid !gYjELVKQn6 04/13/10(Tue)16:33 No.9169828
         File1271190798.jpg-(43 KB, 223x311, 127093_1.jpg)
    43 KB

    Wizards pretty much got to it already...
    >> Anonymous 04/13/10(Tue)16:33 No.9169837
         File1271190829.jpg-(49 KB, 375x523, Chained Horror 2.jpg)
    49 KB
    >> The Heavy 04/13/10(Tue)16:34 No.9169844

    Very good. Costed well.


    Raise the evoke cost by one blue mana (sideboard interactions should be expensive), otherwise fine.
    >> Anonymous 04/13/10(Tue)16:36 No.9169878
         File1271190970.jpg-(48 KB, 375x523, Djinni of the Wish.jpg)
    48 KB
    It now more closely resembles cunning wish
    >> An0nymous !gkWeiOwuW2 04/13/10(Tue)16:36 No.9169883
         File1271190983.jpg-(235 KB, 1280x769, Make_me_proud____by_OmeN2501.jpg)
    235 KB
    >> The Heavy 04/13/10(Tue)16:37 No.9169900
         File1271191033.jpg-(40 KB, 375x523, Dextrous Walker.jpg)
    40 KB
    >> Anonymous 04/13/10(Tue)16:37 No.9169903
         File1271191047.jpg-(41 KB, 375x523, Uncontrollable Desire.jpg)
    41 KB

    Heh heh heh.
    >> Anonymous 04/13/10(Tue)16:37 No.9169910
         File1271191059.jpg-(185 KB, 1600x681, ss9-hires.jpg)
    185 KB
    What about a Mutalisk?
    >> The Heavy 04/13/10(Tue)16:37 No.9169914

    Also acceptable. Hell, the right setup and I might use that.
    >> Anonymous 04/13/10(Tue)16:37 No.9169915
         File1271191076.jpg-(39 KB, 375x523, Ancient Deepsea Rock.jpg)
    39 KB
    >> Anonymous 04/13/10(Tue)16:38 No.9169917
         File1271191083.jpg-(38 KB, 375x523, Sea Wurm.jpg)
    38 KB
    >> Anonymous 04/13/10(Tue)16:38 No.9169919
         File1271191084.jpg-(44 KB, 375x523, Ancient Kraken 2.jpg)
    44 KB
    Really though, I just like making cards to right flavour text
    >> The Heavy 04/13/10(Tue)16:39 No.9169940

    I get that it's a joke card, but if you were making that for real I'd say make it white (white tends to stop attackers more) and lower the cost by 1.
    >> An0nymous !gkWeiOwuW2 04/13/10(Tue)16:40 No.9169962

    'Then again, some ancient terrors refuse to be forgotten'

    >> Anonymous 04/13/10(Tue)16:40 No.9169966
    >it's other types
    You are writing privileges are now revoked.
    >> Anonymous 04/13/10(Tue)16:41 No.9169980
         File1271191273.jpg-(38 KB, 375x523, Uncontrollable Desire 2.jpg)
    38 KB
    >> Anonymous 04/13/10(Tue)16:41 No.9169982
    >> Anonymous 04/13/10(Tue)16:41 No.9169984
         File1271191284.jpg-(43 KB, 375x523, City of Wonders.jpg)
    43 KB
    >> Anonymous 04/13/10(Tue)16:41 No.9169990
         File1271191310.jpg-(39 KB, 375x523, Scorpion Imp.jpg)
    39 KB
    >> The Heavy 04/13/10(Tue)16:43 No.9170014
         File1271191408.jpg-(46 KB, 375x523, Alaborn Handlers.jpg)
    46 KB
    >> Anonymous 04/13/10(Tue)16:43 No.9170016
         File1271191418.jpg-(99 KB, 800x742, 1271143358003.jpg)
    99 KB
    Let's see what /tg/ does with an ambiguously gendered ninja.
    >> Anonymous 04/13/10(Tue)16:43 No.9170019
         File1271191422.jpg-(44 KB, 375x523, Ancient Kraken 3.jpg)
    44 KB
    >> An0nymous !gkWeiOwuW2 04/13/10(Tue)16:44 No.9170032
         File1271191454.jpg-(96 KB, 1023x741, 1270672155623.jpg)
    96 KB
    >> Anonymous 04/13/10(Tue)16:44 No.9170036
    What type of counters?
    >> Anonymous 04/13/10(Tue)16:45 No.9170047
         File1271191512.jpg-(325 KB, 700x800, TheSultansHand.jpg)
    325 KB
    >> An0nymous !gkWeiOwuW2 04/13/10(Tue)16:45 No.9170063

    >> Anonymous 04/13/10(Tue)16:46 No.9170067
         File1271191571.jpg-(857 KB, 1200x848, 1251175739921.jpg)
    857 KB
    >> The Heavy 04/13/10(Tue)16:46 No.9170073

    Very blue flavored. I like.


    Make it legendary and give the counters a name. They need a name of some kind. Otherwise fine.


    Solid little black common, although poison is really more green's thing.
    >> Anonymous 04/13/10(Tue)16:46 No.9170077
         File1271191590.jpg-(41 KB, 375x523, Overwhelming Desire.jpg)
    41 KB
    >> The Heavy 04/13/10(Tue)16:47 No.9170098
    Good. He should at least be uncommon though, and capitalize Island.
    >> Anonymous 04/13/10(Tue)16:47 No.9170104
         File1271191678.jpg-(45 KB, 375x523, City of Wonders.jpg)
    45 KB
    >> Anonymous 04/13/10(Tue)16:48 No.9170106
         File1271191682.jpg-(51 KB, 375x523, Chained Dragon.jpg)
    51 KB
    >> Anonymous 04/13/10(Tue)16:48 No.9170114
         File1271191710.jpg-(41 KB, 375x523, Desert ninja.jpg)
    41 KB
    I was thinking of deserts when I made this, So I referenced both "dehydrate" and "assasinate" with it's abilities
    >> Anonymous 04/13/10(Tue)16:49 No.9170133
         File1271191762.jpg-(38 KB, 375x523, Future Paladin.jpg)
    38 KB

    Pretty much a rip off Knight of Dawn, except less useful. Probably should boost it's power some.
    >> An0nymous !gkWeiOwuW2 04/13/10(Tue)16:49 No.9170147
         File1271191799.jpg-(383 KB, 939x1815, __Warmachine__Legends___4of4_b(...).jpg)
    383 KB
    >> Anonymous 04/13/10(Tue)16:51 No.9170164
    I love it. Very flavourful
    >> The Heavy 04/13/10(Tue)16:51 No.9170172
         File1271191891.jpg-(33 KB, 375x523, Waypoint Flags.jpg)
    33 KB

    it does this
    >> Anonymous 04/13/10(Tue)16:52 No.9170187
         File1271191942.jpg-(44 KB, 375x523, Ancient Kraken 4.jpg)
    44 KB
    this better be the last time :x
    >> Anonymous 04/13/10(Tue)16:53 No.9170202
         File1271191981.jpg-(93 KB, 600x772, 1264917024351.jpg)
    93 KB
    Ehehehehe, it lets you Twiddle.
    >> Anonymous 04/13/10(Tue)16:55 No.9170248
         File1271192156.jpg-(183 KB, 480x360, 1205387062411.jpg)
    183 KB

    what can you make out of this?
    >> Anonymous 04/13/10(Tue)16:56 No.9170250
         File1271192168.jpg-(359 KB, 2100x1582, 1179299102249.jpg)
    359 KB
    >> Anonymous 04/13/10(Tue)16:56 No.9170259
         File1271192186.jpg-(40 KB, 375x523, Otherworldly Duel.jpg)
    40 KB
    Had no good idea for a flavor text
    >> Anonymous 04/13/10(Tue)16:56 No.9170263
         File1271192197.jpg-(433 KB, 1300x830, 1271145110911.jpg)
    433 KB

    Well played, sir. Well played.
    >> Anonymous 04/13/10(Tue)16:56 No.9170266
         File1271192205.jpg-(46 KB, 375x523, Vek, Machine Paladin.jpg)
    46 KB

    Aww, you made a better one than I did. :P
    >> The Heavy 04/13/10(Tue)16:56 No.9170268
         File1271192207.jpg-(38 KB, 375x523, Team Tactics.jpg)
    38 KB
    >> Anonymous 04/13/10(Tue)16:57 No.9170292
         File1271192261.jpg-(192 KB, 800x938, 1180307568574.jpg)
    192 KB
    >> NorinTheWary !PhvIfIiVL2 04/13/10(Tue)16:58 No.9170301
         File1271192298.jpg-(38 KB, 375x523, Hidden Hunters.jpg)
    38 KB
    A throwback to one of my favorite Urza's Block mechanics.
    >> Anonymous 04/13/10(Tue)16:58 No.9170302
         File1271192298.jpg-(39 KB, 375x523, Platinum Knight.jpg)
    39 KB
    >> Anonymous 04/13/10(Tue)16:59 No.9170313
    if it is an enchantment?
    >> Anonymous 04/13/10(Tue)17:00 No.9170330
         File1271192415.jpg-(257 KB, 1000x600, 1255145786230.jpg)
    257 KB
    >> Anonymous 04/13/10(Tue)17:01 No.9170340

    prty AWESOME
    >> Anonymous 04/13/10(Tue)17:01 No.9170351
    Because if it's already turned into a creature, it's silly to have it turn into a creature again.

    It's worded like the Opal, Hidden, Veiled etc enchantments from Urza block.
    >> The Heavy 04/13/10(Tue)17:01 No.9170352
         File1271192512.jpg-(46 KB, 375x523, Salvation of the Chosen.jpg)
    46 KB
    >> Anonymous 04/13/10(Tue)17:02 No.9170357
         File1271192521.jpg-(617 KB, 695x1039, Alexiel_the_Magnificent_by_eta(...).jpg)
    617 KB
    As opposed to being a creature, yes.
    >> Anonymous 04/13/10(Tue)17:02 No.9170359
    It's shit like this that makes modern art look good.
    >> Anonymous 04/13/10(Tue)17:02 No.9170368
         File1271192537.jpg-(38 KB, 375x523, Nothing Left.jpg)
    38 KB
    >> Anonymous 04/13/10(Tue)17:02 No.9170376
         File1271192566.jpg-(45 KB, 375x523, Experience Points.jpg)
    45 KB
    >> Anonymous 04/13/10(Tue)17:03 No.9170396
    Jesus christ that game sucked. Cool robots though.
    >> Anonymous 04/13/10(Tue)17:05 No.9170414
         File1271192700.jpg-(40 KB, 375x523, Armwrestle.jpg)
    40 KB
    >> Anonymous 04/13/10(Tue)17:05 No.9170415
         File1271192704.jpg-(64 KB, 576x821, [large][AnimePaper]scans_Berse(...).jpg)
    64 KB
    Was going to upload a pretty cool Zodd picture, filter said it had malicious code or some shit. Have a Birth of Evil instead.
    >> Anonymous 04/13/10(Tue)17:05 No.9170431
    >> Anonymous 04/13/10(Tue)17:06 No.9170436

    Well played, good sir.
    >> The Heavy 04/13/10(Tue)17:07 No.9170454
         File1271192828.jpg-(45 KB, 375x523, Ruinwalker.jpg)
    45 KB
    >> Anonymous 04/13/10(Tue)17:07 No.9170456
         File1271192841.jpg-(48 KB, 375x523, Apocalyptic Visions.jpg)
    48 KB
    >> Anonymous 04/13/10(Tue)17:08 No.9170474
         File1271192920.jpg-(40 KB, 375x523, War of the Gods.jpg)
    40 KB
    Damn, beat me to it.
    >> Anonymous 04/13/10(Tue)17:08 No.9170479
    I love it when loads of different cards come from the same art.
    >> NorinTheWary !PhvIfIiVL2 04/13/10(Tue)17:08 No.9170481
    A free Vindicate? That's just nuts.
    >> Anonymous 04/13/10(Tue)17:09 No.9170496
    >protection from spells
    Fucking moron

    Also, fuck this thread and every thread like it. /tg/ fails so hard at basic magic design it's not even funny anymore. It's just pathetic knowing that not all of these shitty cards are trollposts
    >> The Heavy 04/13/10(Tue)17:10 No.9170502
         File1271193018.jpg-(39 KB, 375x523, Wall of Weirding.jpg)
    39 KB
    >> Anonymous 04/13/10(Tue)17:10 No.9170505
         File1271193026.jpg-(77 KB, 779x928, friend2.jpg)
    77 KB
    >> Anonymous 04/13/10(Tue)17:10 No.9170506
    >waaah waaah stop having fun guys
    >> Anonymous 04/13/10(Tue)17:11 No.9170523
         File1271193081.jpg-(54 KB, 809x1077, 20thcenturyboys082609.jpg)
    54 KB
    >> Anonymous 04/13/10(Tue)17:12 No.9170542
         File1271193164.jpg-(73 KB, 583x779, The-Man-large.jpg)
    73 KB
    Shit, I just realized one could make an entire thread just using Odilon Redon's paintings.
    >> NorinTheWary !PhvIfIiVL2 04/13/10(Tue)17:12 No.9170544
         File1271193168.jpg-(42 KB, 375x523, Mana Burn.jpg)
    42 KB
    "mana burn will be in m12" -maro254
    >> The Heavy 04/13/10(Tue)17:13 No.9170546

    OP, and kinda fails the Mephistopheles test.
    >> Anonymous 04/13/10(Tue)17:13 No.9170547
         File1271193182.jpg-(856 KB, 708x868, 1256399711712.jpg)
    856 KB
    >> Anonymous 04/13/10(Tue)17:13 No.9170563
    The what?
    >> NorinTheWary !PhvIfIiVL2 04/13/10(Tue)17:15 No.9170587
         File1271193326.jpg-(77 KB, 312x445, 91.jpg)
    77 KB
    I know. I mean, this one retard gave his card Protection from instants. Wizards would never print that kind of shit.
    >> Anonymous 04/13/10(Tue)17:15 No.9170590
         File1271193331.jpg-(331 KB, 907x1200, 673d25ea69e9c99213b264f2b987c0(...).jpg)
    331 KB
    >> Anonymous 04/13/10(Tue)17:16 No.9170594
         File1271193367.jpg-(1.52 MB, 4000x2358, 1250657917477.jpg)
    1.52 MB
    >> Anonymous 04/13/10(Tue)17:16 No.9170601
    actually, protection from spells is legitimate. It just means it can't be targeted by spells on the stack. It can, however, be targeted, dealt damage by and what have you by permanents
    >> The Heavy 04/13/10(Tue)17:17 No.9170612
         File1271193443.jpg-(43 KB, 375x523, Homeward Bound.jpg)
    43 KB
    >> Anonymous 04/13/10(Tue)17:17 No.9170619
         File1271193461.jpg-(197 KB, 2024x2507, Johann_Heinrich_Füssli_008.jpg)
    197 KB
    >> Anonymous 04/13/10(Tue)17:17 No.9170620
    That's different, you fucking moron.

    Everything is a fucking spell. Something with "protection from spells" would be immune to everything but fucking lands.
    >> Anonymous 04/13/10(Tue)17:18 No.9170627
         File1271193488.jpg-(1.62 MB, 2304x1728, 1239225856790.jpg)
    1.62 MB
    >> Anonymous 04/13/10(Tue)17:19 No.9170639
    this isn't true; a "spell" becomes a permanent as it resolves (that is, if it is a permanent, and not an instant or a sorcery)

    See: Emrakul, the Aeons Torn, which has protection from colored spells, but can be exiled with oblivion ring or journey to nowhere
    >> Anonymous 04/13/10(Tue)17:19 No.9170649
    These threads may not be the best but please pack the trollwagon up and go party in /b/ or something.
    >> The Heavy 04/13/10(Tue)17:19 No.9170656
         File1271193596.jpg-(42 KB, 375x523, Wall of Weirding.jpg)
    42 KB

    Well, son of a bitch. Good catch.
    >> Anonymous 04/13/10(Tue)17:20 No.9170660
    Not true. Things stop being spells once they have been cast successfully. They wouldn't have protection from creatures, since creatures stop being spells, they're permanents.
    >> Anonymous 04/13/10(Tue)17:20 No.9170662
         File1271193604.jpg-(117 KB, 600x820, 1213052342290.jpg)
    117 KB
    >> Anonymous 04/13/10(Tue)17:20 No.9170667
         File1271193626.jpg-(48 KB, 768x576, mp2_gallery_10.jpg)
    48 KB
    >> Smirth !1NfcrixV16 04/13/10(Tue)17:21 No.9170683
    Yeah, what the fuck it the Mephistopheles test? Google has turned up nothing.
    >> The Heavy 04/13/10(Tue)17:21 No.9170685

    Actually, it means that permanents could target him, and that sorceries and instants could not. Enchantments could target him as long as they weren't Auras.

    So make some cards of your own. Or better yet, select the gun, select your horse, and get the fuck out. Nobody cares what you think.
    >> Anonymous 04/13/10(Tue)17:22 No.9170699
         File1271193733.jpg-(178 KB, 378x525, magiccard1.jpg)
    178 KB
    I don't think I saw anyone use this picture: >>9169689

    It's my first, so flame away.
    >> Smirth !1NfcrixV16 04/13/10(Tue)17:22 No.9170711
    Needs to have Enchant Creature in the description box.
    >> The Heavy 04/13/10(Tue)17:23 No.9170720
         File1271193812.jpg-(36 KB, 312x445, Chains of Mephistopheles.full.jpg)
    36 KB

    The Mephistopheles test is an unwritten, almost-never-violated rule of Magic card design at Wizards. Any card that has more text/requires more thinking than the card Chains of Mephistopheles is no good.

    Picture attached.

    And don't misunderstand me, with some rewording that card could be good, but right now it's just a little much.
    >> NorinTheWary !PhvIfIiVL2 04/13/10(Tue)17:23 No.9170721
    I assume it's, "Cards shouldn't have rules text longer than Chains of Mephistopheles."
    >> Anonymous 04/13/10(Tue)17:24 No.9170735
         File1271193855.jpg-(81 KB, 564x609, 12480627202962.jpg)
    81 KB
    >> Anonymous 04/13/10(Tue)17:24 No.9170747

    Needs Enchant Creature.

    Also, given how nobody play auras because it's an inherently bad cardtype, it could probably stand to be a bit more aggressively costed - or maybe give it Flash, as a sudden burst of courage.
    >> Crix !!RpOLjtsjwNS 04/13/10(Tue)17:25 No.9170753
    This card is alot easier to understand then that red torment spell that copies a spell for all the targets it could possibly have
    >> The Heavy 04/13/10(Tue)17:25 No.9170761

    That's actually extremely white. However, it does seem a little powerful. You could either boost the cost by 1, or else make it an Equipment at that cost with Equip cost 2. The benefit there being that you can save it for later attachment.

    Good first try though, keep 'em coming.
    >> Anonymous 04/13/10(Tue)17:26 No.9170780
         File1271193997.jpg-(33 KB, 375x523, Elder Tree.jpg)
    33 KB
    >> Anonymous 04/13/10(Tue)17:26 No.9170783
         File1271194013.jpg-(42 KB, 375x523, Ancient Walkers.jpg)
    42 KB
    >> Anonymous 04/13/10(Tue)17:27 No.9170792
         File1271194029.jpg-(166 KB, 1600x1135, 2tze.jpg)
    166 KB
    >> Anonymous 04/13/10(Tue)17:28 No.9170814
    well how could it be rewritten to make sense?
    >> Anonymous 04/13/10(Tue)17:29 No.9170825
         File1271194140.jpg-(49 KB, 375x523, War Factory.jpg)
    49 KB
    >> Anonymous 04/13/10(Tue)17:29 No.9170826
    Art for this, please?
    >> Anonymous 04/13/10(Tue)17:29 No.9170849
         File1271194187.jpg-(126 KB, 619x680, 1263152106777.jpg)
    126 KB
    >> Anonymous 04/13/10(Tue)17:30 No.9170856
         File1271194205.jpg-(36 KB, 375x523, Yggsadril.jpg)
    36 KB
    >> The Heavy 04/13/10(Tue)17:31 No.9170876
         File1271194274.jpg-(42 KB, 375x523, Warblade Berserker.jpg)
    42 KB

    That card was my introduction to the Mephistopheles rule, actually.

    I'm leaving the reminder text in on this guy only because I know how old a rule Rampage is.
    >> Anonymous 04/13/10(Tue)17:31 No.9170878
    that's a tad ridiculous
    >> Anonymous 04/13/10(Tue)17:32 No.9170913
         File1271194359.jpg-(236 KB, 700x350, Kirin6.jpg)
    236 KB
    >> Anonymous 04/13/10(Tue)17:33 No.9170937
         File1271194409.jpg-(29 KB, 374x250, trlaughing.jpg)
    29 KB
    >> Anonymous 04/13/10(Tue)17:34 No.9170950
         File1271194454.jpg-(43 KB, 375x523, Flight of Fancy.jpg)
    43 KB
    >> Anonymous 04/13/10(Tue)17:37 No.9171020
         File1271194671.jpg-(176 KB, 378x523, magiccard1-2.jpg)
    176 KB

    Whoops, forgot they changed that. I'm really more of an old-school M:tG player.

    I like the burst of courage idea, but damn is that text getting small.
    >> The Heavy 04/13/10(Tue)17:38 No.9171041
         File1271194727.jpg-(42 KB, 375x523, Purity Mask.jpg)
    42 KB
    Last night, I created a series of cards using a new mechanic, but the thead 404'd before I got any feedback. If I uploaded the cards (along with the art, if anyone requests it), could I get some commentary on the mechanic and on the cards?
    >> The Heavy 04/13/10(Tue)17:40 No.9171065

    >> NorinTheWary !PhvIfIiVL2 04/13/10(Tue)17:42 No.9171107
         File1271194961.jpg-(35 KB, 375x523, Festering Tombs.jpg)
    35 KB
    Stretching out the gravestones on the bottom gives a neat effect.
    >> Anonymous 04/13/10(Tue)17:42 No.9171109
    There's already a card in Ravnica with that name IIRC.
    >> Anonymous 04/13/10(Tue)17:42 No.9171112
         File1271194968.jpg-(66 KB, 618x933, HeroesV_Academy_07u_Titan.jpg)
    66 KB
    >> Anonymous 04/13/10(Tue)17:43 No.9171125
         File1271195003.jpg-(132 KB, 391x310, andrewjackson2.jpg)
    132 KB
    Challenge your opponent to a boxing contest. Whoever wins, wins the game.

    Challenge your opponent to a dual. Whoever wins goes straight to jail for first degree murder but also wins the game.
    >> The Heavy 04/13/10(Tue)17:43 No.9171131
         File1271195018.jpg-(39 KB, 375x523, Mind Fragmentation.jpg)
    39 KB
    >> Anonymous 04/13/10(Tue)17:44 No.9171147
         File1271195061.jpg-(34 KB, 375x523, Forbidding Monolith.jpg)
    34 KB
    >> The Heavy 04/13/10(Tue)17:44 No.9171149

    There's no laws against dualing.
    >> Anonymous 04/13/10(Tue)17:44 No.9171162
         File1271195093.jpg-(50 KB, 375x523, Phyrexian Factory.jpg)
    50 KB
    over ruled the text... sry
    >> Anonymous 04/13/10(Tue)17:45 No.9171163
    I ment duel. Helps if your opponent calls your wife a whore too.
    >> Anonymous 04/13/10(Tue)17:46 No.9171190
         File1271195185.jpg-(708 KB, 1549x1935, 1262512594613.jpg)
    708 KB
    Let's try a Yian Garuga, given the success of the Lagiacrus...
    >> Anonymous 04/13/10(Tue)17:47 No.9171211
         File1271195270.jpg-(39 KB, 375x523, Yggsadril.jpg)
    39 KB
    Is this better?
    >> Anonymous 04/13/10(Tue)17:48 No.9171215

    OH GOD

    >> Anonymous 04/13/10(Tue)17:49 No.9171244
         File1271195396.jpg-(36 KB, 375x523, Laugh at Death.jpg)
    36 KB
    >> The Heavy 04/13/10(Tue)17:50 No.9171249
         File1271195409.jpg-(37 KB, 375x523, Howling Ashtalon.jpg)
    37 KB
    >> Anonymous 04/13/10(Tue)17:50 No.9171260
    Holy christ that's terribly written.
    >> Anonymous 04/13/10(Tue)17:50 No.9171263
    >Wolf Mutant
    Sounds about right.
    >> Anonymous 04/13/10(Tue)17:51 No.9171270
         File1271195474.jpg-(110 KB, 600x750, trispleased.jpg)
    110 KB
    Only more TR can express my happiness.
    >> Anonymous 04/13/10(Tue)17:51 No.9171285
         File1271195508.jpg-(37 KB, 375x523, Headless.jpg)
    37 KB
    >> Anonymous 04/13/10(Tue)17:52 No.9171291
    Holy shit, what the fuck are you doing?
    >> The Heavy 04/13/10(Tue)17:53 No.9171308

    "into play under its owner's control." should be the end of that card.
    >> The Heavy 04/13/10(Tue)17:55 No.9171359
         File1271195722.jpg-(248 KB, 1000x674, 1270373070400.jpg)
    248 KB
    I expect good things from this one.
    >> Anonymous 04/13/10(Tue)17:55 No.9171369
    image limit reached
    >> Anonymous 04/13/10(Tue)17:56 No.9171387
    >> Anonymous 04/13/10(Tue)17:57 No.9171391
    Image limit reached, time for a new thread
    >> Anonymous 04/13/10(Tue)17:57 No.9171398
    better options for something like that? comes into play, exile some creatures, put artifacts tokens in place... whenever any token leaves play return the exiled version...
    oh, it should be rare...
    >> The Heavy 04/13/10(Tue)18:02 No.9171497
    new thread

    >> Anonymous 04/13/10(Tue)18:20 No.9171923
    Link that shit, bro. If you're still here.

    Delete Post [File Only]
    Style [Yotsuba | Yotsuba B | Futaba | Burichan]