This is a thread created for the discussion of quests and all things regarding them, as well as general whinging about different platforms and fatalistic predictions about the board's future.Please do not shitpost and please ignore at any shit posters attempting to derail discussion or cause strife. Or at the very least make your shitposts entertaining. Outing yourself as severely mentally handicapped for example, while briefly entertaining, sort of derails discussion like nothing else.Useful links: http://pastebin.com/u5xPbk6wThis link contains numerous writing guides, general advice, and various quest tools and communities. It is recommended that you give this a glance if it's your first time to the board and highly recommended if you are thinking about QMing.https://twitter.com/Eisenstern/lists/quest-runner-directory/https://twitter.com/tgquestlist/lists/quest-master-directoryThese are two directories containing the tweets of many current QMs. While a twitter is by no means mandatory, it is a useful tool for both you and your players. To get added to the second list, tweet @tgQuestList. Spamming tweets unrelated to your quest may result in its removal.IRC Channels:[The Cabal] #QMC @ Rizon.net[Hogbox] #ques/tg/enerals @ Rizon.netDiscord server: https://discord.gg/ZgBR5gy(Can provide useful feedback and critique to QMs looking for help and is another way to promote your quest. Is also a way for players to get in touch with their QMs if they are also on the Discord. The only rule is if you need to shitpost at least be entertaining about it.)Archive of quest reviews (It has now been very nearly a full year since the last linked review. This may sound shocking, but people like to hear opinions about quests. If you're feeling saucy then you ought to take a crack at it. It's not like you have a reputation to ruin.)http://pastebin.com/u/QuestReviewsArchive>QM Question:Does player discussion in your quest impact the future events you haven't written yet? As in will you change or add something based on your anons shooting the shit and coming up with ideas.>Player Question:What is a quest you hope to see in the future? (Genre and series included within context)>Player Question 2: Electric BoogalooDo you have a 11/10 moment in a quest you remember fondly? Tell us.>Special lurker question: When was the last time you voted in a quest? Was it a crucial vote? You should probably vote more. Your QM will appreciate it.
>>2618233>Does player discussion in your quest impact the future events you haven't written yet?Sometimes it did, but only rarely.
>>2618268A New Mutant Quest has updated.
>>2618233>QM Question: Speaking for myself, it does add ideas for parts of the quest. I have incorporated ideas from the anons in the threads before, so long as they are make sense to add. The overall quest story-line or layout doesn't change however, as only their choices change that. >Player Question:There's several series I would like to see, some more dead than others. Personally, if someone made a Parasite Eve or Panzer Dragoon Quest, I would be on that shit every evening.>Player Question 2: Electric BoogalooNerv Bridge Simulator had a couple of these, but the best one had to be the assault on North Pole Angel. It started out as a biological sniper battle with an experimental weapon, and ended with the pilots tanking a city destroying angel shot with their EVA's.>Special lurker questionChrist, I actually haven't looked into too many quests in recent months. The last one I did vote in was in Claymore Quest's first thread, on choosing the player character's specialization. I remember actively voting for a few posts and I unfortunately never came back to it.
>>2618278>Parasite Eve>Parasite Eve is a 1998 action role-playing video game developed and published by Square. What?
>>2618233>QM Question:Yup, >Player Question:Shadowrun noire action quest.>Player Question 2: Electric BoogalooThat time we didn't know what scissoring was in HMQ
>>2618233>Does player discussion in your quest impact the future events you haven't written yet? As in will you change or add something based on your anons shooting the shit and coming up with ideas.Should it not? It depends based on how reasonable it is, creativity is creativity whether it comes from author of audience in a quest.Anyways, Futoshi stealing things from Goro!>>2605204
>>2618297It was one of Square's more experimental games before FF7, combining horror and RPG elements in a very modern fantasy setting with New York City as a backdrop. It got two sequels, one of which is ok, and the other is so god awful that they literally couldn't put Parasite Eve on the title. The setting itself is interesting with the whole magic powers coming from hyper advanced biology rather than actual magic. I would love to see someone adapt this into a quest.
>Does player discussion in your quest impact the future events you haven't written yet? As in will you change or add something based on your anons shooting the shit and coming up with ideas.All the time. I always have deliberate "holes" in my plans for players to fill with their ideas. I'd say at some points it's almost collaborative.>What is a quest you hope to see in the future? (Genre and series included within context)I'd honestly like to see a good smut quest.>Do you have a 11/10 moment in a quest you remember fondly? Tell us.Definitely the satellite drop. What a fucking ride up to that point. On the QM side, Bastard's Boars' second thread still is one of my favorite questing experience so far.
>>2607030Chapter 10 of my current project. Have been doing Pokemon quests since 2012, formerly on /vp/, now here. Currently in the middle of my fourth quest, which is a reinterpretation of Pokemon Ultra Sun and Ultra Moon wherein the POV switches between the two MCs with each chapter. My style is lighthearted, over-the-top, and "monster-of-the-week" focused, and battles are a mix of game mechanics with the more kinetic elements you might see from the anime. I detail it better in this pastebin, also has archives for my older stuff.https://pastebin.com/my72UJDuThe earlier quests aren't necessary to understand the current one, but I do slip in lore and reoccurring characters for veteran readers, but again, scholarly knowledge of them isn't required. I don't expect people to read 125+ chapters of material. Catch up on the current one and you're good to go, or don't and just go with the flow. I always welcome new players, so if you're interested, come aboard.>QM Question: Does player discussion in your quest impact the future events you haven't written yet? As in will you change or add something based on your anons shooting the shit and coming up with ideas.Absolutely. Not always, but I have altered and considered altering things based on what I've read my players shooting the shit about.
>>2618233>QM Question:>Does player discussion in your quest impact the future events you haven't written yet? As in will you change or add something based on your anons shooting the shit and coming up with ideas.Of course>Special lurker question: I guess 2015
What is it about quests that makes it so niche? If an artist already as a moderate art following on their social media, whats stopping them from posting a small interactive doodle story updated day to day to interact with their followers?
>>2618614They probably haven't thought of it yet or they don't have the time to produce it at a constant rate while also producing art at the same quality that their followers expect it to be.
>>2618233>>QM Question:Yup. Fairly often, although my quest is malleable enough that I can roll with such ideas harmlessly.>Player Question:As long as it's more OC, almost doesn't matter. Maybe something more like a management sim with a character perspective kinda like how Hive Queen Quest used to be.
I still don't understand why free form roleplay faggots are allowed to be on this board
>>2618614Huge time sink, 100% of my artwork goes to my quest now and I dont even have time to make it quality stuff.>>2618662What did he mean by this?
>>2618233>Player Question:What is a quest you hope to see in the future? (Genre and series included within context)More original setting quests. Preferably ones with systems geared towards working with /qst/ rather than trying to emulate d20 rpgs.>Player Question 2: Electric BoogalooDo you have a 11/10 moment in a quest you remember fondly? Tell us.When Kid died in BCQ. No quarter given for it. Also way back when, the quest where you were a Super Computer AI fighting against God in a post-rapture world. Literally against an omnipotent and omniscient opponent with the only advantage being that the other side had to play by their own rules as well. The final roll of the quest was just fucking unbelievable and appropriate.>Special lurker question: When was the last time you voted in a quest? Was it a crucial vote? You should probably vote more. Your QM will appreciate it.The QM might appreciate it, but when the rest of the players want a shit fetish quest I know that any vote that doesn't rely on the dice working out is pointless so why bother.I just read the threads afterwards. Some QMs are better writers than they are actually running Quests resulting in broken systems or not being able to control player involvement so that they end up with players making retarded choices then bitching when it bites them in the ass.
>>2618365> Satellite drop was a mistakeI actually love when Ouros Quests have things like this happen. Serious repercussions come from these grand choices and he doesn't hand hold people to prevent them from making those high risk choices.
>>2618340I played a fair bit of PE2, and very much enjoyed it. Such a quest would be super cool to see run.
>>2619210Kaleidoscope Quest is up. Sure a lot of giant birds to chase.
>>2611153>>2611153>>2611153Galactic Fleets is running again after some technical issues on my end! Feel free to drop by for some space hulk horror fun!
If furry was allowed on 4chan, how many Sonic quests do you think there would be? Legitimately curious.
>>2618233>Player Question:Mostly more mecha quests, maybe a new ATLA quest would be nice without rock falls>Player Question 2: Electric BoogalooEither when we finally killed Bethany or the fight with Lori in MSPQ
>>2618769>What did he mean by this?"I am irrationally irritated by something that I think I understand a little, but actually don't understand at all."Think: "I hate anime because I saw DBZ and didn't like it."
>>2618278PE needs a lot of backstage work to bring up to speed. You need a little bit of biology to dig deeper at MITOCHONDRIA, a fair bit of knowledge on shooty things, and a direction that might have to steer completely clear of 3rd Birthday.But I wonder how strong of an impact PE would have if you don't play it as Aya Brea.
I'm running a little, simple quest based on Mecha from a game I played. It mainly relies on dice rolls added onto base stats. Along the way, you can try to recruit certain enemies as they try to invade your base. The goal is to get to the enemy base, and that's how you win! It's just a simple, likely short, quest to see some robots hit each other back and forth.>>2610070>>2610070>>2610070
>>2619506>how many Sonic quests do you think there would be? Legitimately curious.Too many.Legitimately curious why you'd think of this, how you expected anyone to estimate this, and what you hoped to gain from asking this.
>>2618233>no crusader quest sequelWhy live?
>>2619506>If furry was allowed on 4chan.>Implying furry isn't allowed on certain boards on 4chan like /trash/ and /b/>how many Sonic quests do you think there would be?None, like now.No one's stopping you from running a quest with anthro characters, hell, I recall a drawquest where everyone was an anthro character, though I can't remember what it was called, just that the MC was a cat and the entire quest took place in a modern day town.Anons are just conditioned to view anything remotely anthro as bad wrong and to autistically shut it down even if there's nothing sexual or fetishistic about it. see >>2619651Having anthro characters can be a nice aesthetic choice to make your worlds seem more alien, to make it more lighthearted or better suited for slapstick, it also brings up nostalgia of the lighthearted adventures we saw as kids like Duck Tales, Robin Hood, Redwall, Looney Tunes, ect.Honestly, furry quests should be allowed on /qst/, even shitty sanic the hedgeheg or Zootopia ones, let them be and let them die from lack of players because if we ban those quests just because they feature anthro characters then by that same token we'd have to ban potentially amazing Redwall or Mouse Guard quests too, and if you think making something like pic related verboten for a quest just because it's anthro I don't know what to tell you other than you have the taste of shit and should reevaluate your life.
>>2619823>Duck Tales, Robin Hood, Redwall, Looney Tunes, ect.One of these things is not like the other...
>>2619823content like red wall and blacksad =/= furry.Its not the same thing.
>>2619883How is it not the same thing?Anthro is anthro, and anthro = furry in the eyes of pretty much everyone.You can't pick and choose.
Hey I'm back and continuing Teen Titans Quest after a prolonged absence due to personal issues. The Halloween Party has turned into a warzone (as they always do) and Fearsome Five have something up their sleeve.
>>2619573No, you people are just fags.
>>2618233>Player Question:>What is a quest you hope to see in the future? (Genre and series included within context)Just OC settings. Maybe a sci-fi western set in a humanity so far flung and with such massive communication gaps that there's no real central authority. We'd essentially be galactic hitchhikers along the shipping lanes that connect habitable systems, religious seekers, historians, brawlers, idk>Player Question 2: Electric Boogaloo>Do you have a 11/10 moment in a quest you remember fondly? Tell us.The end of Left Beyond quest. That quest was the single best executed quest I've seen so far on here IMHO.
>>2620076>that OCI’m working on something really similar.
>>2619823Excellent points.I think I automatically translated "allowed on 4chan" to "able to be posted on 4chan without incurring negative attention severe enough to make it not worthwhile".I stand by my opinion that none = too many, however.
>>2619651I realize it sounds really dumb, but I was thinking about fanfiction, and knowing there's a ton of Sonic stuff, I was wondering if anyone would actually run such a thing as a quest. I'm going to go ahead and admit that I enjoy both the concepts of classic Sonic and the Freedom Fighters of Mobius, but I can't stand the overall direction the more recent games went in (though, Generations and Mania were great).
>>2620302The Freedom Fighter stuff basically was fanfiction that got made into a cartoon, then published through the Archie Comic series.I think if somebody did one, it would be set in the Generations or Mania-like universes, as the success of those games and the relative failure of something like Sonic Forces makes it kind of easy to bring in fans.On the other hand, the Classic games series don't have too much leeway in what you as a QM can do to bail yourself out of trouble, whereas with the FF stuff you literally have to be SOMINUS to fuck it up and die.
>>2620302>I was wondering if anyone would actually run such a thing as a questDoubtful, you have to remember that the fanfiction scene of the sonic series is populated largely by children and a bunch of CWC level autists.Chris Chan level autists don't really become QMs, let alone the kids that lurk the boards hiding their underageb& status.Besides that, and this is my subjective opinion, the design of the Sonic characters is just overall unappealing, the uni-eyes, the proportions, the completely naked save for gloves and shoes males, it's just bad, and I think a lot of people think the same which is why I believe it's more likely you'll find other quests of anthro franchises with more appealing designs or straight up OC before you'd find a Sonic quest.
>>2619823>>2620302>>2620319>>2620398While Sonic might not work, more quests like Redwall, Mouse Guard or pic related would be great imo
>>2620398>fanfiction scene of the sonic series is populated largely by those that don't really become QMsThis>the design of the Sonic characters is just overall unappealingI'm with you.>which is why I believe it's more likely you'll find other quests of anthro franchises with more appealing designsThis is where you lost me.The idea of a QM choosing whether or not they'll run a quest based on the appeal of the character art they might use seems downright odd to me.
The real question is when are we getting a Sonichu quest?
>>2618233>Player Question 2: Electric BoogalooBeheading giant robots and ice quakers.It didn't feel good, but the village of constant buzzing in your ears was truly unsettling.Flinging a giant ball of flesh zombies straight over the walls of the capital and into the residential district just to open the door.Outplanning, outgunning, and outrusing a mad scientist without a single casualty.Watching everyone kill a gore magala expy while not only ignoring but outright avoiding the summoner that revives it.Guessing a major mechanic of a quest in the same post that rolled the Nat 1 to trigger the mechanic.
Was this not a sonic quest?>>2618960
>>2618233>QM Question:Sometimes, if I like it. It really depends on how I feel about the suggestion.
>>2620539>This is where you lost me.>The idea of a QM choosing whether or not they'll run a quest based on the appeal of the character art they might use seems downright odd to me.Character art has little to do with it, you're looking at it from the wrong angle, even if you didn't use pictures, the world you'd try to show the players would still be tainted by unapealling design.Overall aesthetics plays a part in one's desire to run a quest, and how characters are supposed to look plays a huge part in it, nothing odd about it, it's why a QM chooses to run a post apocalyptic quest, for example, despite the world being a dead cesspit of radiation and the people filthy and hobo like. It's still pleasing on an aesthetic level, it's why a QM might run a western quest, despite the arid, inhospitable frontier being unsightly and filled with rough people.It's just not something QMs usually think about because they naturally gravitate towards what they like when writing.Case in point >>2620543Would you run a quest if you had to keep in mind the characters that inhabited the world you're presenting would look like that when writing them?>>2620586Kek, Quest is still delivering prime shitposting hooks I see. I still fondly remember when players went on a buddy cop esque demon hunt with Nicholas Cage and Steve Buscemi that culminated in a duel of the titans against pic related, good times, I really need to catch up on the sequel.
>>2618233>What is a quest you hope to see in the future? (Genre and series included within context)Besides the one I plan on running, a good civ would be cool, but I really wanna see more freeform type draw-quests like the recent 'adventure dude'>>Special lurker questiondo people actually lurk on /qst/? Why?
>>2620609>do people actually lurk on /qst/? Why?Yes, because they prefer reading rather than playing.
>>2620613But why? Like I read old quests all the time, but actually playing and contributing is so much fun, sometimes I'm the only person in a quest for long periods of time, why would you not vote? it seems silly not to, it's not like you're gonna lose anything from posting, you get to read it all the same and you're QM will know more people care
>>2620596>Overall aesthetics plays a part in one's desire to run a quest, and how characters are supposed to look plays a huge part in it, nothing odd about itNope.Not seeing it.Rarely do you see character appearances mentioned in quest pitches, for good reason.If someone doesn't want to run a Sonic quest and chooses not to, I sincerely doubt that the character design aesthetic was the primary reason.
>>2620619Many quests require reading previous threads to understand the context of votes, and some level of consideration when proposing plans. Civ quests are most notorious in this regard.
>>2620623>require reading previous threads to understand the contextwait if you just wanna read quests wouldn't you want to start at the beginning anyway? it doesn't make sense to me to just start reading a quest that's been running for a while without reading any previous threads and then not voting even when you're caught up
>>2620627I read quests when they're in a catalog. When I both play in multiple quests and read them, it's impossible for me to afford the time to go through the archives for all of them. Also sup/tg/ doesn't work properly for me at the moment.You can generally tell the quality of quests and how much you'd like them by reading through the active thread anyhow.
>>2620627>it doesn't make sense to me to just start reading a quest that's been running for a while without reading any previous threads and then not voting even when you're caught upSome questers aren't in the mood for that.
>>2620628>Some questers aren't in the mood for that.that's like opening a book to a random page and starting there because you don't feel like reading it from the start, or because you just wanna see if the writing is good
>>2620638Which one are you replying to?
>>2620641It doesn't matter they're both (you)
>>2620644You're replying to different answers to different questions. You linked to one and quoted the other.
>>2618233>QM Question:>Does player discussion in your quest impact the future events you haven't written yet? As in will you change or add something based on your anons shooting the shit and coming up with ideas.Sometimes. I’ll oftentimes gauge player interest in certain things I’m debating on adding. I personally think more QMs should talk with their players in the downtime between runs.>Special lurker question: >When was the last time you voted in a quest? Was it a crucial vote? You should probably vote more. Your QM will appreciate it.I haven’t voted in a quest in months. And I certainly don’t roll, my rolls are always awful.
>>2618233Pq:Anything involving naval battles, or even space ship battles. Like old Privateer Quest by Machine SpiritLurker question:I'm following 10 quests right now, some of them I only lurk because they run while I sleep, or like Guntz quest that runs on the weekends and I have to divide the attention with my family, but he's making some weekdays posts so'll be able to chip in more
>>2620609>a good civ would be coolSpeaking of that, I'm working on a civ right now. It's gonna be like that "Actually hard civ quest" game that ran a long time ago. Anybody got tips/suggestions?
>>2618233I just want hive quest, death among the stars and house and dominion to return to their previous glory. This board gets too little traffic for those things to be filled like before, coupled with irl issues for the quest makers its a bad feel man.
>>2620319>>2620409Interesting. I guess my next question would be how well-received would a quest styled like Mouseguard do if it were set in a grim future where a not!robotnik has basically won, and the protags are fighting for their freedom?
>>2620794HQQ is a funny one in that, too. Even on /tg/ there'd be times where QD would only get 5-8 responses to a post until something everyone feels is important (or funny) comes up and 50 previously uncommitted lurkers surge forth with hot opinions. So even when responses were low, you knew they were there. Just waiting for the humans to do something incredibly fucking stupid again.I would say we need more good commander style quests, but they become harder to run over time and kill their QMs pretty often.>>2620759Nothing that's not generic advice, plan for every bigger stage, use excel if you're into torturing yourself, etc.
>>2620912A New Mutant Quest has updated.
Out of curiosity, what would anons think of a Necromunda quest? It’d be based almost entirely in the original game, since that’s what I have all the magazines and rulebooks for and I have no idea what the fluff for the new game is like. Would probably start out as some street urchin, with the eventual option of joining one of the original six houses, but maybe I’d add the option to start as a Ratskin or Spyrer, not sure.
>>2620620Do you QM or write stories?
>>2620923Just remember that the rules as stated in TTRPGs often are not compatible with /qst/ formats such as best of three or anons making exceptionally bad ideas that result in character death.So either give your PC plot armor, or have a way to quickly generate new characters.
>>2618233>What is a quest you hope to see in the future? (Genre and series included within context)More science fiction quests that are not mecha or space opera. Something like Blade Runner will scratch the itch nicely. >When was the last time you voted in a quest? Was it a crucial vote? You should probably vote more. Your QM will appreciate it.I vote all the time, even on quests I barely follow, just to give the QMs (you)s.>>2620699>Anything involving naval battles, or even space ship battles. Like old Privateer Quest by Machine SpiritNaval exploration quest was great. OC, non-smut and outstanding worldbuilding. Howard best character ever.
>>2620999Oh yeah, didn't mean I'd actually use the Necromunda rules, otherwise characters would be dying left and right. Would just be making use of the setting and fluff. I think I'd probably just do Bo3 with d100s for actions the players take, probably with the occasional bonus tacked on depending on what they're rolling for.
Is akun more lenient with update size and schedule than /qst/? What I mean, quest that don't update frequently, or whom updates are too big tend to die pretty quickly here, unless they have survived long enough to have commited players. I have not seen this happening on akun. Do quests even die of no votes in akun?I know that akun players are shit, but at least there are players.
>>2621091>Do quests even die of no votes in akun?YesYou just don't see them cause they go to the bottom of akun's 'Wall' and no one wants to navigate that site more than they have to.
>>2620759I'm working on one too.I'll post the rules I'm cobbling together when I finish them, eventually.The best advice I've found has been to know what you're getting into before you start.Civ thread QMs need to accept that it's work and involved.I personally wanted the support of a clearer rules system.The less you have to fiat and figure out as you go, the less work you have to do at once while running.
>>2621091As far as big updates go, I'd recommend attracting the players at the start of the first thread with whatever makes your quest cool, then starting with the large updates after the first session.Starting a Quest with a wall of text is generally always a bad idea.Also, accepting steady handfuls of votes is better than chasing after the prize of "more" (You)s.If you're not enough without the prize, you'll never be enough with it.I personally like big updates.
>>2618233>Player Question: What is a quest you hope to see in the future? (Genre and series included within context)I remember there was a Wild Cards Quest based on the Weird West tabletop setting of the same name, with the main character getting the 3 of Clubs, but it only got to two threads before petering out. I'd like to see it tried again, or even just a generic Weird West quest of some sort.
>>2621092>no search functionhow does akun get away with this?
>when your rivals quest stats bleeding playersI know I shouldn't, but I hate that fucker so god damn much.
>>2621138Which quest lad?
>>2621140The quest thats too similar to mine to mention. But his players should be my players
>>2621150I wouldn't mind being one of your players, as long af the quest is good.
>>2621150Yeah, but what quest does that cunt run? I can help you out with your rival if you lend a hand in bumping off my rival.
>>2621154>as long as it's goodThen you are probably already reading my quest>>2621155I'll never go that far
>>2621121Oh it has one but it's shit.
>>2621162I dunno, I took a long hiatus from /qst/ and have been tryto get back into the swing of things and I've just been following one shots and such. I could use a good quest series to hop into besides the occasional nbs update.
>>2621193What oneshots have you liked?
>>2621091Once you have a decent following, you can get away with infrequent updates. But unless you write smut, you'll have a hard time getting followers there. >>2621121There is a search function but the tagging system is too inconsistent for it to be useful.
>>2621155>Yeah, but what quest does that cunt run? I can help you out with your rival if you lend a hand in bumping off my rival.But what if YOU are his rival?
>>2621150Slime Quest/Slime Time?
>>2621229>But what if YOU are his rival?Then we can be friends and put aside our differences.
>>2621138>tfw all my rival quests have disappeared>tfw I wanted them all to keep going>>2621150>But his players should be my playersHow do you know they don’t play both?
Shilling this quest bday present >>2593325>>2593325
Demonologist Quest resumes, this time with something actually happening.>>2600932>>2600932>>2600932Play as Marcus Fowler, demonologist, heretic, traveling merchant, and fate's latest chew-toy. Summon demons for fun and profit, avoid the inquisition, fail at avoiding the inquisition through no fault of your own, and try not to get broken on a wheel anyway.
are we still ded?
school quest is live>>2621374>>2621374>>2621374
>>2621138>Having rivalsMy quest is one of a kind it has no rivals.>>2620973>>2620973>>2620973Expect another live session soon.
Any of you gentlemen know when DLID is coming back?
>>2615276Teen Titans Quest is back on.
Hey guys I'm doing a World of Darkness Quest and I need a little point of reference. Does anyone remember the name of the quest where an anon was running Change: The Lost? I need to look into his interpretation of the storyteller system.
>>2621816You could search for it on sup/tg/.
>>2621826I don't know the name of it though, so nothing of note comes up. Even when I put up 'World of Darkness' in tab it doesn't really show. I'll try again to see if it works though.
>>2621848What was the QM's name?
>>2621859fuuuuuck, I played that and can't remember the name, is it the one we were the hobo fairy? it was awesome
>>2621848>>2621882How long ago was the quest?
Anyone else feel relieved as fuck when someone votes in your quest?
>>2621903in the short time that I quested, yes. I had already come in expecting bland or dumb votes, but no votes at all stabs in a deeper way.
Code 214 - DiTF, Prelude III is up:>>2621868
>>2621193ill scoop you up if youre looking for a home. If you can handle some dark fantasy fun give my quest a read. >>2621242<3
>>2620923/tg/ has plenty of Warhammer shit. There's no need for it here.
>What is a quest you hope to see in the future? (Genre and series included within context)Hard to say. I have a few ideas for quests that I would like to see, but at the same time I dread the idea of a popular QM taking a tangentially similar premise and running something I'm not interested in, and I feel that I can't trust anyone but myself to run quests I want to see.The quests I pick up generally aren't ones with premises that would have crossed my mind had I not seen them in the catalog. Guess I like to be surprised.>>2619506Going by the demographics on tgchan, not many I think. And for Sanic in particular you could get past the "furry" aspect by focusing on the fast and beating up robots.
>>2621859I completely forgot what his name was.>>2621893The quest was years ago, around when /qst/ just began. He was around when that popular Fallout Quest with Courier Six was happening with the Enclave. Thats what I remember from the year, but the OP from that time didn't make that Fallout Quest, he was doing Changeling: The Lost.
>>2621882Yeah thats the one I'm looking for!
I've been watching the AUX quest and it seems really interesting, it reminds me a lot of ruby, what do you guys think of it?
>>2621987Shot in the dark, but was it hoboquest?
>>2622087Nope, didn't work. I typed it in and it showed me Hobo Mutant quest instead.
>>2621987Man, I was the one that came up with the plan to give an empty box to the true fairy that came for us, one o my ballsiest and stupidest momentsI have some tips tho, I remember I was following that quest that had naval battles and steam ships, we even found an evil red medalion or something, it was a drawquest, anybody remember that one?also, it had a roguetrader of a mercenary house running parallel too, maybe with this info we can find itI remember thinking at the time that one of the reasons that quest didn't have more players was because the name was convoluted and dumb, I guess I was right
>>2622248I remember the MC was named Jerry something..That quest was beautifully written and what got me interest in the other aspects of WoD. I was mostly only interested with Vampire the Masquerade, but I got more interested in the Changeling and Mage after.
>>2622248>I have some tips tho, I remember I was following that quest that had naval battles and steam ships, we even found an evil red medalion or something, it was a drawquest, anybody remember that one?This Wretched Seafuck that was a good one
>>2622274FUCKING FOUND ITLost in the seventieshttp://suptg.thisisnotatrueending.com/qstarchive.html?tags=Changelingand here is the thread were I troll a demi-godhttp://suptg.thisisnotatrueending.com/qstarchive/1321440/I really liked this quest, shame I couldn't keep up, the QM was awesome.The name kept most people away in my opinion
>>2622323Thanks bro! Your a hero!
Does anyone know how to archive?
>>2622557yeah you just go to sup tg and put your thread number in he box
How do I implement "opt-out" in a quest? I've never done it before and some players are pressing me over it.
>>2622773What kinda opt-out are we talking about here?
>>2622773>>2622775>What kinda opt-out are we talking about here?This.Any option to avoid the entire situation is a mistake.
>>2622773I have no fucking idea what "opt-out" is supposed to mean, and I've been here for years.So I had a look.>It's an argument about waifus and route locking/choicesthere's your problem: VN logic. Or it's your players. Flip a coin.
>>2622773>>2622870Do it like Joker Quest. There's no lock-in, you just keep digging yourself deeper.
>>2622870if they are using VN logic you can throw VN logic right back at them, if they don't choose the girls end up mad and leave his ass. I don't remember which one did this but I know I saw it in a VN
>>2618233Excuse me, been a hectic weekend. I am up again>>2596629>>2596629>>2596629
>>2621072I recommend outright stealing Black Compaby Quest's combat system.
>>2621816It's Vox running Cinderella Sanction quest
>>2622951When will we see the likes of Left Behind Quest ever again :/
>>2622289It came back for like two sessions and then disappeared again - feels bad man
Someone run a quest about enchanting with the sigil rune system(Banished Quests enchanting was based on it)The new sigil system is shit though but if you run it I'll toss you the book
>>2623419I'd rather make my own magic system that's been customized to the quest itself. The system has a lot of good stuff to borrow, but its context in the lore and relative power is what made it so potent. For a quest about enchanting I feel like you'd need several somethings more, BQ's enchanting had a lot more going on around it in the magic itself and Soma changing rules and meaning around to be more efficient.
>>2623448Just make a quest with an enchanting system at least vaguely based on sigils so I can use my autistic knowledge of it that currently has zero use
Actually does anyone know what's up with Cindarella Quest? Vox only uses tumblr which is hot fucking garbage to navigate without reawli g through his shitposts of "OMG does Mrs mean owned by a Mr?" Like Tumblr isn't necessarily garbage but his kind of is. Which I don't give a fuck about because the quest is good, but once again makes figuring out if he's dead or not kind of a pain.
>>2623714It's on hiatus for June due to family get togethers and such.
>>2623714link it to me, I would like to see how someone handles a quest on tumbler
>>2623870Just google Vox Cinderella Tumblr
>>2624070A New Mutant Quest has updated, muh muggas.
>>2623419>>2623448>>2623452You guys want an idea? How about making an enchanting system even more like a language? The system Soma was meant to be like a coding language rather than a spoken language.
How do I into dialogue? I don't talk to people outside of work about work things and haven't done so in years.
>>2624813Make a quest where every dialog occurs on an imageboard, then just write there as you write here.
>>2624813Go to the library, or a cafe or ride the busWear headphones so it looks like you are listening to somethingListen to people around you talk and take note of it.
Whatever happened to the SpookyG/Ghost Thread?
>>2624813Read. Read a lot. Read stories that are heavy on character interaction. Dialog is one of those things that you just have to pick up through exposure, and if you're not exposed to a lot of it in real life then you need to compensate by supplementing your dialogue intake with artificial injections.Also try reading the scripts of plays, aloud to yourself if possible. Plays tend to feature characters talking a lot more than most books, so it can help you develop an ear for dialogue. Then try practicing by writing stories in a script format. Then read the story back to yourself. Then do it again. And again. And again.
What quest, old or new, has a really good story and good writing?
>>2624879Homeless Mutant Quest. Characters, romance, and plot all in one. It was so good A New Mutant Quest ripped off its format and in someways its premise.
>>2624879Why would i read any quest if i didn't think it had good story and writing?
>>2624879Valen Quest. It's truly exceptional for character development and worldbuilding alone. Not just the MC but all the characters in it, even the minor ones, have their own fleshed out roles.
>>2624879Any of Moloch's quests
Where can I read more about [Skirmish] type of quests like this >>2604283 one?I played one way back for a bit and want to know the format more and check out few examples.
>>2624949I don't think you can read _about_ them anywhere. But for more examples you can check out >>2596515б as well search suptg.Or I can try to answer your questions I suppose.
>>2624950Look at >>2596518 , there are many little things that seem important but aren't explained.There is no legend that would let you understand what half of those symbols mean, its implied you should already know this shit like a back of your hand, even when its the very first thread.And the fact that they are drawn while very cute and nice-looking rises an additional problem - is this symbol the same as that one just drawn a bit differently or does it mean something completely different?I was hoping those types of quests are somewhat bound by similar and already established rules, given most of those I seen act as you are supposed to already know how mechanics work before joining in and don't go into details.
>>2624963Oh. That.I'll be frank: I'm playing this skirmish and I had (and sometimes still have) all the same issues.This particular GM is notorious for having poorly explained rules, many of which rely on knowledge of his past games, as well as not remembering his own rules and changing rules without writing it down anywhere. You pretty much have to ask other players in the thread or in Discord.That his games have insanely high player count despite all that speaks volumes to how awesome they are.I can give you a rundown of that rulesheet you linked, if you wish.
>>2624973If you're not busy, sure.Hopefully it would be enough for me to make a char and check out for myself just how awesome this GM and that game of his really is.
>>2624989Just give me some time to get home. Probably an hour or so.
I'm sorry for being dissapointing and being unable to write anything of quality. Goodbye
>>2625013>Another rival dead
>>2624749It's funny you mention that, that's literally the human system of magic in my setting for a custom pnp game. Only written though, humans were made to forgot how to speak it.I wouldn't recommend anyone putting that much effort in unless they're very sure its gonna get use, though. Making magic a language with its own conventions and rules is difficult, static or not. It has the better quarter of challenges in making an actual language while having balance considerations based within accessory developments that make sense for the setting as a whole. You can take inspiration from ancient or foreign language rules, but taking them wholesale also gives you those problems in your language, and you have to choose which bugs/features you think are best. Retranslating structural rules to be more suited to your intent and borrowing conventions to simplify into a dynamic system of magic takes a metric fuckton of no life. If someone doesn't enjoy languages or making systems in general they really shouldn't do it just for the sake of having it.There's also the actual writing part, if you want to make it so players can see the language itself and you're not just describing it, hoping they get it. It's a bigger thing in pnp, but for an imageboard if you're telling me you made a language for your magic system and the character knows what it is and you also describe the letter parts or the sounds of it you should be able to write it out and show the parts the character knows and how they think it works. That's at the least. Reasoning being, that was the monumentally great thing about the Sigil system and others like it. You could see it. After seeing enough of it, you could just photoshop up something that worked.If someone doesn't want to do all that, they can still have it in their quest. If you trust your system improvisation skills, just fucking cheat. Steal any parts of systems that work well enough together that you like and slap some symbols on its ass and go. It only has to look and feel functionally complete from the player perspective. To have depth, just make the character and players not have perfect knowledge. Done. There's also many more ways to make language based magic than there are magic systems in existence, so it's not like you're limited in path either.You just have to be a good bullshitter.
>>2625021I don't think I could've ever been considered a rival.
>>2625024Everyone is my rival memes aside what quest lad?
>>2624989Let's do this.First, some basics:-Each player controls one character-Joining the game is as simple as posting a character sheet and >deploy-Each player can make 2 acts (actions) per turn-An act could be moving, attacking, changing weapons, interacting with objects-Movement is in cardinal directions only, but attack ranges also count diagonally-There are also tap acts, which are like free actions-Taps are used to use some active abilities, reminding of passive abilities, looting and other stuff-Some actions are once-taps, which are taps that are usable once per turn-To attack, you roll 1d100. On less than 50 you deal only half damage, you can also miss altogether on a very low roll or deal more damage on a high one.-All actions are posted in greentext. It's customary to enclose skill names in [square brackets] and preface tap actions with a -dash.-Each post also contains the character's stat sheet. Since it can grow rather big, by convention people only post their full charsheet once per thread then just link to it.cont.
>>2625113Now to the explanation of pic related. Let's look at the Jaeger class:A: jaeger's base stats and the formulas for the derived stats. From the top:-HP equals VIT multiplied by the racial modifier-Damage is STR x weapon damage-Armor and magical defense = RES x def, where def is 1 + equipment bonus. Your rear armor is halved. Some items also give separate front armor.-Magical power = INT x focus bonus. Irrelevant for jaegers-Movement range = SPD / 2 + 1. All fractions round up.-SP = PER x racial mod. SP is spent on some skills.-Vision range = PER x lighting modifier (depends on time of day)B: available races and their modifiers. For example, humans get +1 movement range, while kerbolds (dogmen) get +1 STR and SPDC: starting armorD: starting weapon options. The bow has range of STR x 2 + PER and damage of PER x 2 + arrow modifier. The daggers have damage of STR x 5 + 5 and two weapon artes, which are skills tied to items. In this case [Adroit Fighting] allows you to deal damage with SPD instead of STR, and [Knife Throw] allows you to throw the dagger at range = STR. I know this only because I asked in Discord.H: full starting stats for each race, accounting for race and gear modifiers.E: jaeger gear proficiences. Better confirm these in the thread.G: class ability. You have it as long as jaeger is your main classF: class skills. You get one on start and can buy more with insight. Most have two ranks. Your class level is the number of class skills you have. You keep them even if you change classes.A minor note: Lv4 skills are actually available starting with Lv5, since you gain a level after you get a skill, not vice versa.J: how this class earns insight. Insight is your XP and each point allows you to buy a rank in class skill, or learn an arte from an item you used this mission, or learn a skill from a scroll, etc.There is another advancement currency called merits. You gain merits for notable deeds in the mission and can use it to raise stats or gain a secondary class.You can only earn 1 insight and 1 merit per game day.General notes: -Melee classes generally suck because they have to spend acts to get to the enemy. -Magic classes are OP, but have the most rules and rulings that constantly change in an effort to nerf them and are complex AF. -The easiest to level up are sworn and longcoats (just don't die), after them it's shrine maiden/keeper (just perform [Last Rites] on a corpse).-Teamwork is essential, but hard to achieve.
>>2624989There's also a new skirmish with better formatted rules: >>2625081
>>2625033Nah, you're too small time to be my rival
>>2625129>The daggers have damage of STR x 5 + 5Could you explain this bit?Damage dealt is STR * damage modifier.Daggers have x2 damage modifier per hand and +5 on top of that, so shouldn't it be STR * 2 + 5 resulting in(for humans) 4*2 +5=8+5=13 damage dealt per hand(so you attack two times, once for each hand)? What does 'pot' next to +5 actually mean?
>>2625524Say that again.
>>2625610smol waifu needs to stop trying to get into the big leagues and go back to school.
>>2625806Oh shit you are right, wait... I have two arms bitch I can strangle you both
>>2625013I know how you feel.But still... the desire to run is pushing against that despair. Maybe one day I'll try again.
>>2626584Why are there three?!
>>2626782> he doesn't know you can have sex with more than one personMy sweet summer child.
Free aspiring QM advice: if you’re tempted to begin writing a quest, make sure you run something you would actually want to play.
>>2627077A New Mutant Quest has updated.
>>2625606It might be that +5 is only on a Knife Throw.I don't know, I never used it.'Pot' means 'potency', which is for attacks - damage, for heals - amount healed, and so on.
Does anyone remember what happened to Diesel Empires? I loved that shit, but I haven't seen it up in a long ass time.
>>2624879>What quest, old or new, has a really good story and good writing?Joker QuestShadow QuestElder Loli Quest
>>2626793That's absolutely ridiculous. Next you'll tell me that people can sleep for less than 8 hours.
How far do you plan your quests? I've got a few big things in mind.
Is there or has there ever been a good Fate quest?
>>2620834Yeah, I really miss Hive Queen Quest too. Anyone know anything from QD and how he's doing?
>>2627817How can a good quest come from a bad franchise?
Any good hard-boiled detective / film-noir quests?
Is it difficult to make a Gotham quest?I want to make a half-mad MC with a dash of Hannibal series. Mostly focusing on Arkham asylum management
>>2627989Right now I'm trying to find a job while working on crunch stuff for the quest to return, hopefully soon. I have a lot planned for when it does though, big things.I also made an account with WorldAnvil just to see how it was and made a quick article for it. It will probably be replacing the ask.fm and the wiki as the repository for setting info, since it looks like it has built in methods of communication as well as being much more easy to edit and fill out than the wiki, but apart from the one article I made to test it out I'm mostly just working on getting things back into motion first, and then I'll probably start filling that out over time later.https://www.worldanvil.com/w/hive-queen-quest-QuestDroneStill, don't expect me to respond on the ask anymore, since I've just been ignoring it since they started doing shoutouts, and now I just get dozens of spam questions from random people, both shoutout and normal.
>>2628373>big things>hopefully soon>working on crunch
>>2628408A New Mutant Quest has updated.
Anyone know what happened to warlord QM?
>1-10 unique IPsNew quest, it's ok>10-30 unique IPsNiche quests>30-60 unique IPsGreat quests, everyone should be reading>60-80 unique IPsFan fic but good80+ unique IPs meme waifu pokemon fanfic shit what if anime magic girl but seen from this power trip perspective :^)) eat shit a billion flys cat be wrong quests
>>2628435I guess I run a niche fanfic quest? Kind of fits.
I'm thinking about starting a quest. I haven't browsed this board much since it's creation, I mostly played around on /tg/ back in the day. But kinda wanted to get back into it since I remember always having a great time. I've settled on a few different possible topics, thought I'd see which one (if any) had any interest. I'm probably garbage since it's been so long, and even back in the day I was slow to respond since I like to write a bunch and also get distracted easily while I'm writing. ANYWAYWhich of the following quests have some appeal to you? Mage Quest - Start as a fledging talented mage and try to become a god / goddess of the arcane Fantasy Mercenary Quest - Start with a small group of friends, try to grow your merc company into a force to be reckoned with. Mass Quest - Start as a small blob of flesh and really just kinda go any way with it. Absorb other flesh to gain their flesh related abilities or just as pure mass to use for other purposes. Are any of these appealing / Over done? Like I said I've been absent for forever, probably have no business running a quest but hey, here I am.
>>2628480Mass quest, stay away from fantasy themes
>>2628483Why's that? They super overdone? Or just boring and not too interesting?
>>2628490I don't want any competition
>>2628493Heh, well, I've been out of the game for a while. I'm sure I'd only serve to make you look better by comparison.
>>2628480Mage Quest: I have an explicit love of Mages and getting gud. You got a magic system worked out for this or something?
>>2628512If I do the mage quest, the magic will be pretty touch and go. Magic is mostly elemental based. Y'know, fire, water, wind, earth, with light and dark thrown in as well. You'd be able to choose 3 of them to be at a beginner level in, or 1 of them to be specialized in. (Like, you can be pretty fucking solid with fire, but not have anything else going for ya, or can have a wide variety of weaker magics to go on) It's probably best to pick the 3 magics over the one, since it'll be more expensive to pick up new fields of magic later, but not so much so that it's unmanageable.
>>2628480Mage or Merc Quest. Why not put them together? Mass quest sounds like it would run into problems early on, most of them being "What do?". But as long as you have cute girls you should be fine.
>>2628560If Magic is going to be touch and go, but you're going to have 5 options, might I suggest not having any actual formal spells as such but instead have levels in the different elements count as die to roll against a DC? Like each level gives you another die to roll, mixing elements costs vefore rolling 1 die for simple spells and increases with difficulty.So a flame spell with 3 levels in Fire would give 3 die to roll with 1 die needing to pass the DC for a simple spell, 2 for a spell + effect, 3 for a complex effect, etc. Extra die after 3rs level could be spent to try and increase strength or duration etc.Whereas a combination spell that used say light and water to create an illusion clone would require 3 water die (summon water, shape water, manipulate water movement) and 2 light die (create light, manipulate as an image) for the spell itself but also require an extra die from either the water element or light element to represent the concentration needed to double cast elements.I would probably allow for players to "burn" extra die for the session to reroll their lowest roll to make unused levels picked earlier more useful.That way players magic investments stay relevant while providing benefit for both specialization or generalization of skills in different magical ability while allowing /qst/ format of multiple people rolling.
>>2628047The premise is good, myths and legends fighting each other, however the franchise panders too heavily to weebs.
>>2628480>I'm probably garbage since it's been so long, and even back in the day I was slow to respond since I like to write a bunch and also get distracted easily while I'm writing. Thats fine, /qst/ is a slow board>Mage questLet me guess, another quest where you start as a mage and try to become an all powerful deity.>Fantasy Mercenary QuestPlaying as a sellsword is good, remember to flesh out contractors.>Mass QuestSeems boring if we are just growing for our biological need to grow, maybe at some point we gain consciousness.
>>2628729The idea was more "attempt to cast a spell (provided it exists in a magical domain you are proficient in) Some spells are harder, some situations add difficulty, and some stuff is just outright more complex. Multi-tiered rolls isn't an idea I'd formed already, but I didn't like, have a spell list preformed or anything either. So, say you wanted to use something like a steam jet attack.roll 1 die for fire (low dc since it's only boiling the water) and 1 for water (which is the *real* dc check, since this is the directional attack where the complexity lies.) HIgher skill with water in this case can help lower the DC depending on the what you're trying to do, but I'm not going to make you roll multiple water dice unless you're trying to do several different things with one water based spell casting roll. Does that make sense? Like, a roll requiring multiple water rolls would be like "Shoot a water bullet at them, and then freeze the bullet on impact" So you'd roll once for the water shot, and once for the freezing action. Also, how do you read 5 options out of WaterFireAirEarthLightDark>>2628766>>Mass Quest>Seems boring if we are just growing for our biological need to grow, maybe at some point we gain consciousness.I didn't really specify, but you start with some low level intelligence, and ramp it up as you gain power. Depending on the direction the quest goes, I was thinking it'd wind up as you sort of being the over brain for your fleshy conquest. Slowly infesting areas and gaining new biological intelligences, allowing you to build up a host of varied minions for the domination of the modern world. You're basically right about mage quest, and the merc quest is something that would be kinda difficult for me to run, but ultimately rewarding just based on the amount of unique characters I'd have to plan in order for the ranks to swell properly. If I do that one, I'm going to try not to just fill out the ranks with >Generic archer x 40< or whatever. I want it to be more a coalition of champions who can each be off doing their own things when they need to be.
>>2628782Already stole this shit, in fact in honour of stealing it I worked theft into the quest itself.>>2628798Don't talk, do.Come play. Or take it over maybe. Let's throw shit at the wall and see what sticks.
>>2628906Haha well, since I wasn't sure whether I was going to do that one or the mass quest, I'll just run the mass quest and play in yours as well. Thanks for making the decision easier for me lmao.
>>2618614Just gonna rep awful hospital, look it up and thank me later
>>2628935>>2629004Mass quest is up. Who wants to see this trainwreck unfold in real time?
>>2628480>>2628480definitely merc quest for me, having to recruit new guys, dealing with constant losses, cool character for contracts and different things to see and do in new locations. sing me upI've been playing battlebrothers latelly
>>2613914We could use more players in Sword and Sorcery quest.
>>2628373Sorry to hear about the Ask spam. Hive Quest = best quest, so hope you can get back to it soon. Good luck dude.
I ask of you: What is your preferred method of getting into the proper mood for writing?>>2629092>We could use more players in Sword and Sorcery quest.So tell me then; What is it about, the title aside? What may a reader see? What can they experience? What mood does the story convey and how would you describe the atmosphere between players and storyteller?>>2628766>>2628480>Mage questIt'll be incredibly important to provide a measure of flexibility in casting. Players love to experiment and exploit.Lacking that, a collect-a-thon for artefacts would work.>Mass Quest...you don't want that. Trust me. It tends to draw A Certain Crowd, shall we say.>Fantasy Mercenary QuestThere's been a couple, few successful. It really depends on how well you trust yourself in writing action AND character interactions AND how well you can deal with players siding with the last faction you expect them.Oh yes.>>2629453Erika Quest is live. Come, witness the trials and tribulations of a young goddess and, perhaps, steer her towards a future more radiant than even she might have imagined!
>>2620673>I haven’t voted in a quest in months. And I certainly don’t roll, my rolls are always awful.Awful rolls are better than no rolls.
Why are their so many cringy namefags in that slime quest? It seems like a fun concept, but the namefags are turning me off the quest.
>>2629558>Fetishbait questGee I wonder
>>2629558Welcome to why I think Mass Quest is gonna end up with the unpleasant kinds of surprises for >>2628480 this gentleman here.
>>2629506It's a quest set in the World of Conan the Barbarion, We're playing Alexandros, a Adventurer that has currently helped lead a crusade of the Sun God's faithful against a forest of fey creatures and the Litch leading them.
Hey guys! Back from a long absence and willing to get back into QM'ing now that life is being more gentle to me. I have the notes from a few past quests and am more than willing to resurrect them if you guys are amenable.>Silent Stars:Space Piracy and a dash of horror and catgirls>Warlord Quest (yes this was me). Butcher tribals and religious zealots.>Shellstorm: Pilot a mechanized walker and fight in Alt-past WW2>Gunslinger Quest: Journey the wasteland and deal with its various inhabitants.Which do you guys want back?
>>2629660>CursedQm>>2629660>>Warlord Quest (yes this was me). Butcher tribals and religious zealots.Was this the mutant one?
>>2629664No, I ran under the tag WarlordQm
>>2629660>>2622040>>2622040>>2622040>>2622040Necromancer Detective is upWE'RE LIVE AND THE NEXT CASE BEGINS
>>2629506> I ask of you: What is your preferred method of getting into the proper mood for writing?36 hours of consciousness.
>>2628225dunno if mine qualifies but I am going for mysteries, its strictly low fantasy which lends itself better to the thematic. Honestly this is my first quest, and the first two threads have some grammar issues. Regardless, I'd recommend it.
>>2629660>>Silent Stars:Space Piracy and a dash of horror and catgirls>Shellstorm: Pilot a mechanized walker and fight in Alt-past WW2any of these is good
Alright /qtg/, I have a proposition for you. I have the leisure to run a quest, on which I have been ruminating about for some time. The problem is that I don't know which you guys would prefer:>"Blade Quest" set in a relatively low-magic, dark fantasy world where the main character is a sentient mystical weapon that must cooperate with it's wielder. (Or not). Unique combat mechanics have been developed and tested for this one to do it justice.>"Quarantine Quest" where the main character's fictional, modern-day hometown has suffered from a nuclear fallout. Missing the civilian evacuation has lead to being locked inside the city with the remaining denizens, which have begun to mutate.Both sounded appealing to me at least, but some feedback would help so my efforts can be focused to optimize the experience. There is still much work to be done and a consensus would be conducive to getting one of these ideas off the board and onto the table, so to speak.
>>2629576Here's to hoping it doesn't, but oh well if it does. I'll just wait for them to shoot themselves in the foot and start one of the other ideas I had ruminating. >>2629773Thanks for the positive reinforcement, I hope it continues to.
>>2628435Unique IPs are just a SMALL indicator of questiness. You need to consider:>OP to Player reply ratio.>Average amount of replies between OP's updates.>Player image post ratio.>Lifetime fan art count.>Suptg upboats.>QTG metions. >And how many days between thread start and the threads end.
>>2629775I tried that once. Pretty sure I might have accidentally written blatant fetish quest in the aftermath.
>>2630199>all those factors >each of them super low in my questlow questiness...yay
>>2630199Fuck man Lorekeeper is writing one of the better quests and sometimes only one person can because he has terrible timing.
>>2630209Have you considered cocaine?
>>2630415A New Mutant Quest has updated....again.
>OP to Player reply ratio.I disagree, QMs have different styles. >Average amount of replies between OP's updates.Good indicator, pretty much always proportional to unique IP count anyway>Player image post ratio.Meaningless>Lifetime fan art count.Dictated by if you have a drawfag reader or not. Bad indicator of anything.>Suptg upboats.Only shows oldfag reader count>QTG mentions. I disagree, its basically people just jerking off the same 3 quests over and over. People shat on fatoshi quest yet that dude got 30 readers. I would honestly say most people don't even use /qtg/>And how many days between thread start and the threads end.I dont understand what this indicates.
>>2630462>People shat on fatoshi quest yet that dude got 30 readers.>Fanfic quest about recently popular anime gets large playerbase
>>2630465im just saying qtg is not a good indicator of anything. If 1 more guy starts sucking off crusty and ignoring all the great quests in the catalog im going to blow my brains out.
>>2630470I didn't even know this general existed until the very end of my last quest.
>>2630470Lots of them aren't that good. People like HMQ, so they recommend it. It's why a lot of the recommended quests are the same. Whereas in the catalog quests there's, what Lamplighter that you might look at and think of as a top tier quest. Can't see any others.It doesn't mean they're fellating the QM, it just means they like the work. Especially when the guy wants it to binge read.
>>2630474>Lots of them aren't that good.What did he mean by this?As an aside, I'm sure I speak for more than a few people when I get irritated that people recommend dried up old shit instead of at least fresh stinky wet shit. I swear to god, once I asked for reccs of currently running quests and people STILL recommended the same ancient quests that died around the same time as Ramses the fucking Second kicked the bucket. Fuck's sake, if you can't think of a newer quest to recommend that's at least not been dead for YEARS, why are you even still here? Clearly every reason you had to stay is long gone.>hey man you're looking pretty greenDamn straight, I could lie down on the lawn right now and nobody would ever see me.
>>2630527It doesn't mean that I don't read them, It just means that I don't think they're as good. Easy.
>>2630537So you read them, but instead of directing people towards them so that they might get better from more feedback, you point people towards old and dead/finished things first? On a board where the key feature is player interaction, the first place to point is a place where no more interaction can be had? No development can take place, nobody discusses things really other than shilling for them?Instead of these ones that are so not as good that they can be collectively dismissed in one fell swoop, such is their mediocrity.Do I have that right? Because I suppose I can't argue with that.
>>2630569No, I just assume that anyone posting a recommendation thread is going to have looked at the things already available in the catalog. If something is an absolute standout, sure, I'll put it in. But nothing there is enough that I'm going to say "Hey, I like these, but I also really like this, so if you haven't also checked it out, or given it a chance but didn't like it, maybe check it out again".
>>2630527I recommend new AND old shit though.
Quest pitch:>You're part of a privateer crew on-board a ship with your brother as the captain. >You were recruited alongside a few other ships like yours to explore a new planet found by the edge of known space - a place where a lot of ships have gone missing as of late.>Upon arriving to the planet and getting close to the surface, every single privateer ship lose all their powers and crash onto the surface.>Bruised, but alive, you intend to find your brother who was last seen disappearing down below the surface.>delve deeper and deeper into the planet.>Strapping relics and strange creatures onto your body to use as weapons to survive, gradually turning into something inhuman to find and save your brother.>Find the corpses and survivors of the other crashed privateer ships. Some sane, and other insane. And some changed forevermore.>Everything is hostile.
>>2630727This isn't really critique, but open question to everyone:Is this more interesting than Spiral Knights Quest?
>>2630727good>>2630732what is spiral knights?
>>2630727Go for it. I'd probably play. Not least of all because there's - presumably - a logical end point in getting off-planet.What can you tell me about the setting?>>2630569>but instead of directing people towards them so that they might get better from more feedback, you point people towards old and dead/finished things first?The board's so slow that honestly makes more sense since 70% of /qst/'s living quests are going to exist on the catalogue at any given time.>>2630380....let me guess: Asian timezone?>>2630023>I'll just wait for them to shoot themselves in the foot and start one of the other ideas I had ruminating.Pfff- Won't take long, I wager. Quest players tend to go for a Chairman Yang run given the opportunity.>>2629951Blade Quest, hands down (pun unintended).>>2629589I don't play fanfic anymore (I think the last one I followed was Makai Knight and that died as all of JQOP's non-Joker side projects tend to) but this might just work.
Random unrelated thought: I really fucking respect MercCommand's incentive and endurance.
>>2630900His stuff can get kind of samey but damned if he isn't consistent. I think I've seen him miss one scheduled session in recent memory.
>>2630574>I just assume that anyone posting a recommendation thread[request?] is going to have looked at the things already available in the catalog.Valid assumption.Terrible conclusion.Just terrible.>Waitress asks restaurant patron if they're ready to order>Patron asks the waitress what she'd recommend>Waitress says that they used to serve a really amazing dish that she absolutely loved that they don't serve anymore but the patron could find elsewhere>Patron asks why she didn't recommend something the restaurant currently serves from the menu>Waitress says she assumed that the patron already looked at the things already available in the menuMaybe they looked and found the selection too dense.Maybe they like fantasy, sci-fi, and anime and can't decide where to start.Maybe there are 6 or 8 fantasy adventure quests being updated and they don't have the free time to read all of them to gauge them themselves.Maybe they're worried they might have missed a gem in the mix.Maybe they just want to hear your opinionYeah, they should check the catalog before asking.But then, they can ask about it.
Hey guys, new QM here, I'm running a quest. >Corporate Enforcer Quest>>2630890Take control of a newly hired "Security" Guard in a world dominated by the interests of corporations and dictated by financial bottom-lines.
>>2630892>Not least of all because there's - presumably - a logical end point in getting off-planet.If you're saying that a quest with a logical endpoint, or definite end goal, is a turn off, I don't understand.I understand the appeal of open quests, but quests with defined ends provide some promise of eventual closure or finality.Quests with no end in sight ever only promise that the quest will die when the QM tires of it, however long that takes. And when it dies, it will not truly end, just simply stop. This will leave the players unsatisfied and pining for its return or sequel.Plus, any quest that reaches the end point with plenty of gas in the tank can just change the ending, and add a new chapter.
>>2630727Good premise.Solid potential.As presented here, it seems like there's a chunk of narrative to get through before you get to the heart of it.Be mindful of that and keep the start of the journey as engaging and interactive as the quest will be or you'll turn off some players.If you start off on rails, which is understandable, hide them well.
>>2630727could be good
>>2629951>"Blade Quest" set in a relatively low-magic, dark fantasy world where the main character is a sentient mystical weapon that must cooperate with it's wielder. (Or not). Unique combat mechanics have been developed and tested for this one to do it justice.Stuff like this has been done before both on /tg/ and tgchan. Most of the time it gets dropped/abandoned for some reason and not because it's unpopular.
>>2630805A little bit of shilling here. If you feel like having a bit of a Toku Time after waves of MG quest, come right in I just updated.
>>2631005>If you're saying that a quest with a logical endpoint, or definite end goal, is a turn off, I don't understand.I said the exact opposite of that.
>>2630980Man, you really are a faggot.
Evil Sorceress Quest #16 is live!>>2631250>>2631250Today, we go to meet our family for the first time since being exiled from the capital. Join us if you like!
>>2629514I gave three 1s in a single thread. On d100s.
>>2631331you should strongly consider chopping your hands off.
>>2631358That’s why I don’t roll anymore.
>>2631413Roll now, anon. I want to see your curse.
Rolled 40 (1d100)>>2631420>inb4 100
Rolled 15 (1d100)>>2631422you did your best.
Rolled 55 (1d100)out of my way, low rollers>>2631331also can you link the thread? I'd love to see it
Rolled 73 (1d100)>>2631458Lucky roller, coming through.
Rolled 21 (1d100)>>2631420If I crit I'll run ny quest after a funeral
Rolled 72 (1d100)>>2631420
>>2631458Shit I can’t remember, it was in either in Som’s Dragonball quest(Tofoo) or Kato’s Tuffle Quest, back I think in 2015/16. Doesn’t narrow it down by enough to really go on, sorry.
>>2631842A New Mutant Quest has updated. Return of the Arachnid edition
Rolled 81 (1d100)>>2631420>>2631738What happened in the thread?
Demonologist Quest resumes.>>2600932>>2600932>>2600932Summon demons for fun and profit, deal with not-so-random-screening by demons, stay cool as a cucumber when demons show up in the dead of night, and try not to get broken on a wheel.
Gantz: Quest Episode 6 returns with a rude awakening.>>2632213>>2632213>>2632213Second half of the slice of life for week 3 starts now with some psychic bullshit and paramedics.
>>2631738Ohhhhh.That quest was the spawn of one Martian Triggerman.>>2631262>doing it wrong.jpeg>>2631181Kamen rider a shit. A SHIIIIIIIIIIIIIIT.>>2629660Which one has the highest amount of sawmouthed ojous and flexible musclelolis?
>>2631190>I said the exact opposite of that.So you did.Nevermind then.
>>2633085>>doing it wrong.jpegI'm afraid I don't know what you mean, friend. I saw you posted in the thread but I didn't understand that either.
How true is it that anons always vote for/to do/to be the nice/the "right" thing/"good" no matter the context, quest, premise, characterisation or anything else? Or at least seek "redemption" or to be some lame antihero at beast.Is there any way to avoid it? To disencourage it?Some counterexamples maybe?
>>2633870Give bonuses for being an all around douchebag to be a better douchebag. At the very least, have there be more consequences for doing the "right" thing.
>>2633870It's true of people in general, and anons are people. It's just that people's definition of "right" and "good" are really flexible.Generally, no one IRL tries to harm people just to be evil. It's always "because they deserved it", or "because I had no other choice", or "it's for their own good", or "it wasn't really harm, stop being so thin-skinned".You can't discourage it, but you can make the players turn around at the end and realize what shits they have been. At least some of them.For inspiration, read Snakecatcher.
>>2633870> How true is it that anons always vote for/to do/to be the nice/the "right" thing/"good" no matter the context, quest, premise, characterisation or anything else?False. I have seen plenty of quests where people would choose to do terrible things, they just would always try to spin it as being just. A ridiculous overreaction to a perceived slight is a common way you get evil choices in quests, especially if they think that letting something slide would make them look weak. Conversely, anons will go berserk at a perceived betrayal by an NPC, even if that betrayal was preceded by the players treating the NPC in ways far beyond what they would tolerate themselves. It's very easy for a QM to play with that double standard to manipulate anons into making extremely evil choices. All while believing that they are just, of course. It's always the fault of the NPC for not having thicker skin.Apologizing for anything is also absolutely anathema to many anons because they think it makes them look weak. No matter what is at stake, if you make the good/nice/right thing hinge on an apology, there's a good chance that the anons will refuse to choose it.
>>2633917>Apologizing for anything is also absolutely anathema to many anons because they think it makes them look weak. No matter what is at stake, if you make the good/nice/right thing hinge on an apology, there's a good chance that the anons will refuse to choose it.Valen Quest laughs at you. It laughs so hard it hurts.
>>2633870>How true is itNot very.Depends on the quest.I've seen chargen spin botb directions.>Is there any way to avoid it? To disencourage it?Don't make a "good" mc.Don't offer options that go against character.Don't faithfully obey write-ins that break character.In Peasant Lord Quest, when write-ins for dropping the girl the mc was in love with dominated, the QM didn't just cave, he reflected the internal conflict but kept the established course the mc was on and did not change the character.In chargen for a quest with a BBEG type as the mc, I asked for an action that they did it the past that would cement their character as evil.One we landed on was corrupting, destabilizing, and destroying a noble order of righteous knights because they wouldn't lend us a book we wanted to read.>Some counterexamples maybe?Actually haven't read many evil mc quests. As I recall, I'd say Reno from DC Quest counts as "not good".I can't say exactly how they discourage it, aside from sticking to the established character very well while still allowing flexibility.
>>2634087>One we landed on was corrupting, destabilizing, and destroying a noble order of righteous knights because they wouldn't lend us a book we wanted to read.What quest was this? Did it work?
>>2633870In my current quest (Dark Magical Girl quest) we've been avoiding that so far. Players chose to mentally break our former friend because of their betrayal, even when given the option to walk away after savagely beating her.Then again, I've hard blocked redemption arcs, and i'm up front about that.
>>2633917Are you saying most anons are socially maladjusted to the point of being extremely spiteful over minor story elements?
>>2634290Not the other anon. More often than not, yes. Presentation helps a lot. More diplomatic ones are less prone to this.
Sup fellasI feel like writing something but I don't have a brainExperiment time, anyone?Pitch me some quest ideas and I'll write one RIGHT after I wake in in like 9 hours
>>2634308Wild West quack doctor quest. Players must sell enough snake oil to make ends meet while also getting out of dodge before the townsfolk catch on and lynch them. Bonus points if other get-rich-quick schemes are included such as search for a lost gold mine that may or may not actually exist. As the MC moves from town to town he or she will potentially be threatened by hostile Indians, outlaw gangs, wildlife, and/or the elements. The biggest danger, however, will be if anons can avoid blowing all their money on whores, gambling, and booze in order to purchase enough equipment/bodyguards to survive their high-risk lifestyle.
>>2633935IT IS A GOOD PAIN wait not please stop oh god we didn't mean this why is this happening.And then Riz explains and it all clicks and Anons realize that they're terrible.Because any failure at all is unbearable.In reality Irue Valen is a bad ass bitch that is getting shit done, because nobody could actually be expected to fix all the things she wants to fix. Including solving two Ateliers or completing THREE testaments instead of just the one she was required to. Which was a mistake to decide to do and we will absolutely overconfidently choose similar stuff in the future.God, just thinking about having to give up Ari, or even Carona, just to save the world or whatever, it fills me with angry spite.
>>2634091Working title was BBEG Quest or Evil Fantasy Villain Quest.Technically never got off the ground.Chargen went great, developed a solid mc, worked out a solid outline for the first session and several paths for the quest to go in.I just needed to brush up on some mechanics I was rusty on...And then the curse hit and I haven't had more than a few minutes of spare time at once since.As for whether or not it worked, I'd have to say yes.In the chargen there were a couple anons gave quality responses to the question, one anon who gave a half serious one, and only one anon that questioned the purpose of it and wanted to explore how the villain felt justified in his actions. I simply explained to that last anon that the point was that the character was a villain and a villain is defined by his villainous acts. And then I thanked him for his questions.
New Quest: Wars of the Free is running>>2634373
>>2633870Here's the thing. Reality has an implicit xGood bias.Players will try to win. Oftentimes being some sort of Good will be advantageous, so you'll simply need to provide options that provide advantage outside of good/nice actions.TL;DR: Pay them.>>2633634Hahahaha. Such is life.>>2634308-Galactic Peacekeeper Quest. Think of a mix of Valerian And The City Of A Thousand Planets, Perry Rhodan, Andromeda and Stargate.MC is a recently-minted agent of the Terragen Confederacy who uses a mix of diplomacy, intrigue and planet-obliterating firepower to ensure the galaxy's balance of power never tips too far towards War And General Unpleasantness.-Travelling Shaman QuestTalk to spirits, make salves, try not to get murdered by The Church(TM)>>2634418What's the pitch, good sir?
>>2634341>Caring about Carona>At allIf we ever require a large scale ritual blood sacrifice to pacify some angry beast, I will have never been happier.
So>>2633907>>2634452mechanically encourage it>>2633909provide aditional context to the "evil" actions>>2633917Prety revenge is my best friend.>>2634087Keep the options in character and disregard overly out of character write ins.>>2634277I know, your quest is what made me ask the question, but I still think that anons are holding back and only did it because of, lest say, the joy of beating a little girl to nerd dead. Also they did that becouse other options were "worse" in some way.Solid advice overall, I am going to read Snakecatcher.
>>2634454I feel like our sense of responsibility outweighs our hatred if the town.Like. We'll make it better out of spite.
>>2634719>>2634454And then we'll price the residents out of the area! Gentrification FTW.
Just saw on GraveQMs Twitter that death among the Stars Quest is on temp hiatus as he works on a sidequest he plans to debut next weekend.In his last thread he said it would be a mercenary adventurer quest based in the city his original Ghoul Civ Quest took place under
>>2634308DeadworldPost apocalypse with the only life being the undead, of course the majority are mindless and violent, unlike you.
Hey I'm doing an Exalted quest if you guys want to check it out. Hijinks, conquest, and just good plain ol' ass kicking will go down>>2635361
Alright guys, I need some help on a decision I've been thinking over. I'm working on a quest right now and I'm stuck on if I should have combat include a battle map for each scenario. Battle maps being something akin to how World Tree and others similar to it have combat. Personally think that the bonuses of the added tactical advantage and the ability to see where you're positioned within the world space really helps anons plan out combat maneuvers and attack orders. The system itself is all in the works right now but I'm leaning on something like Black Company's dice system, it being centered around d100s.
>>2634308>>2634329>>2634452>>2635368Well shitHere is where I remember I can't write anything but fantasyBut I've already written something that's sorta Traveling ShamanSo let's do something about zombies?>>2635672
>>2635571You should try it without the battle map then add it as needed, requested, or after you've tested the mechanics without it.
I been thinking on running a fallout quest but I am not sure if I add the SPECIAL system or even how to implement it. (this would be my first quest and I want to get it right) I am reading a few fallout quest so see if I can come up with something but some help would be nice
>>2635792Base it on the best Fallout Fallout 2
>>2635792I'd like to see something involving trading and/or scavenging, as well as bounty hunting. Maybe some base building options, too.
>>2635808>I'd like to see something involving trading and/or scavengingThere was one a long time ago on /qst/. The qm bailed on it, and has came back a couple of times to run fallout quests but they all seem to die pretty quick.
>>2635818Fallout Trader, right? I was there for that, yeah. Sucks that we couldn't get to make our floating brothel before he bailed.
>>2635840Yeah it seemed like a pretty solid plan desu.
>>2635799hmm I already have a some sort of story, that takes place around that time, what I could do is introduce few characters from f2>>2635808not sure about base building, I think I can do scavenging and trading.I dont want to spoil too much but it wont be related to the courier or the lonewanderer, the mc is going to be a supah mutant. How about it? but then again I am not sure if I add the special system
>>2635846I know! Fix up a pre-war yacht complete with hot tub, fix the place up, staff it with ladies and ladyboys, bring a nightkin in as a bouncer, and we'd be living like kings!
>>2636034A New Mutant Quest has updated. we a cripple edition
>>2635792Just play fallout 1 and 2 a bunch, make a bunch of different characters with different special and pay attention to what each attribute affects
>>2636445I am a bit of a profligate, I have only played 3,nv and 4. I have a good grasp of how special works is only that my mc would only be affected by only a few and I am not sure how to implement it since it would be my first quest
>>2636499I'm tellin' you man FO1/2 are great games, even playing one of them for 2 hours would help you understand how to use special. Seriously every good FO quest I've ever seen just uses the same system as the games for special and combat.
Okay, I had a thought.>Someone starts at civilization thread>an anon sees it in the catalog after it's been up for a little bit>Excited to finally get a chance to join in on one they open up the thread>they see that the race choice has already been decided even though the the thread has only been open for a short while>What's worse is that some of the anons who voted for that race never post again in the threadLet's ignore the terrible survival rate of civ threads for a minute.When civilization threads were on /tg/, it made more sense for the first of three decides the race rule. If and when I run the one I'm planning, how long is a reasonable time to wait for the players to decide the race?Would posting in the QTG that I was going to start the thread several days in advance give enough notice?Just just thinking about these things as I'm tooling my ideas around.
>>2636727The reasonable thing is to not have a race decision at all. Run something already defined so that, for one, you actually want to run it, and two, you skip the stupid preamble and actually get down to business instead of holding a ceremony where you have half the potential players fuck off while the people interested in staying wait with their thumbs in their asses.
>>2636750>one, you actually want to run itAlready handled by not even presenting races or choices I'm not interested in.>two, you skip the stupid preamble and actually get down to businessThat preamble is a big part of the initial appeal of a civ thread.Isn't it?All the different possible elements honed and defined by player input?Opening open the chocolate box and all finding out together what the creamy center is?Am I wrong?>half the potential players fuck offThe players I lose because "dwarven tundra communists" was chosen are likely to have been lost whether the thread decided it or if I had decided it from the start.>the people interested in staying wait with their thumbs in their asses.This is a valid concern.Ideally, my players would have frosty, alert thumbs.Hence my dilemma.How soon is too soon?How long is too long?How many licks does it takes to get to the center of chilled monkey brains?
>>2637048>Am I wrong?Yes and no. If the appeal in playing a civ game is the choices which surround the beginning of the game then it wouldn't be a big surprise that their average lifetime expectancy is less than a house fly. The appeal in playing in a civ game isn't the initial box of chocolate but the choices that surround playing a civilization god game, or being a leader of a group of outcast dwarfs, or the brave king of giants who struck out to find wealth with his lucky half a dozen brothers and sisters in arms. It's not exactly about the giants or the dwarfs, it's about the experience of playing the group. Like playing dwarf fortress, it's not about whether you're playing dwarfs or goblins or orcs, its the set up and the challenge in surviving and growing a civilization through technological, superior firepower, or the sheer will to survive against all odds. May it be enemies at the gates, civil unrest, or the environment trying to subdue you, it's your job to challenge them back and defeat them, or die trying. tl;dr - It's the experience and challenge of playing and managing a civilization, not the initial choice of said civilization.
>>2637381True.That's why I specified "initial appeal".It's like when you go to a strip club for the tits but come back for the damn good coffee.
>>2637462You're missing the point anon. Also that's a pretty bad analogy to civ threads. Since you can come back for coffee, you can't come back to the civ thread for that same "coffee" since it's taken the first time. You don't go to a strip club for the coffee, you go for the tits. You don't go to a Civ thread for the choice. You go for the management.
>>2637508Give me your hand, sweet child.Let me walk you through this:>Since you can come back for coffee, you can't come back to the civ thread for that same "coffee" since it's taken the first time. The "race choice" is the stripping in this analogy.The coffee is the potentially enjoyable civilization management.You can come back for that.Honest mistake, let's move on.>You don't go to a strip club for the coffee, you go for the tits. You don't go to a Civ thread for the choice. You go for the management.Again, I was talking about INITIAL appeal. The thing that gets anons in the door.The vote.The power.The choice.The control.The tits.The anons interested in managing whatever choice gets decided are the regulars who've seen the tits and just want to enjoy the coffee.You say you don't go to a strip club for coffee.I say you've been to the wrong civ threads.Because some have the best damn java this side of Juan's burro.And I've got the beans to prove it.
Civs are like a box labeled as assorted chocolates, giving you the expectation of varied fruit cream and crunchy nut centers, then when you get to opening the box they're all just malformed masses of coconut with the thinest layer of chocolate drizzled over them. And it's not even that halfway decent coconut either, but that imitation paperboard shit that kinda tastes a little like coconut but not really.
Darling in the Franxx Futoshi quest live!: >>2637698
>>2637671See>>2636727>Let's ignore the terrible survival rate of civ threads for a minute.Yes, our chocolateers are working with rancid corpses in the giant bar of chocolate (any Bones fans?) but we're dealing with theory and potential ideal here.
>>2637744The best civs limit to like 5 or so races that the QM would want to play
>>2634452This is more of an introduction to the new series meant to establish a few core concepts and rules before the actual start.But it's a dark, high fantasy setting which aims to capture some of the more 'interesting' aspects of the medieval era.
>>2636727It makes more sense for someone to pitch a race/background combo in a general, a couple anons to show support for it, THEN a CM looks at which combos have a lot of support and decide they want to write that.But noone can be assed to keep a civ general alive(me included, I'm burned and jaded the fuck out on civs), and that does nothing to stop the slow bleedoff of players anyway, since marketing tactics are even less effective for civs than they are for quests.
>>2638181>high fantasy settingso gay wizards everywhere and some magical faggotry behind every bush?
>>2638263No.While magick is plentiful it just means there are a few magickal creatures and races.Not that there are flying carts and teleporters everywhere.
How strict are the mods in regards to the erotica rule? I know they obviously wouldn't allow straight up porn posting on the board but how about something like:Non-lewd = in the threadLewd = link to a pastebin?
>>2638311You could lewd it up in the thread all you want as long as you don't make the OP too obvious or piss someone off to spam reports.The mods are the opposite of strict with regards to enforcement. Just look at Fuck Quest.
>>2638317>You could lewd it up in the thread all you want as long as you don't make the OP too obvious or piss someone off to spam reports.This, I wrote about some poor under-aged girl getting buggered.
>>2638294On the one hand, I like priests/monks even less than wizards but I have to admit your setting seems pretty decent even though I'm a low/no fantasy kind of guy.Fighters and rogues don't get enough love on here. Duelist especially, I don't know that I even remember a quest with a duelist as the MC.
>>2638353Just give it a second.Read the next thread when the story actually begins.The graveguard is just the tutorial dude. He's not the MCThen you'll have a better idea whether you'll like it or not.
>>2638317I think the issue with mine compared to Fuckquest is that it would be almost entirely comprised of surprise sex and I know a lot of people tend not to like that. It's also quite the departure from my completely normal mostly non-lewd writings because I wanted to do something very different that I was inspired to do. How about I post my (no doubt controversial) idea for a lewd game quest and feel free to shit on me/it.There is a greenskin (of various types) invasion from the mountains of a kingdom's northern frontier, said kingdom moves a hurriedly assembled force to face it. The readers control what actions the greenskin army take throughout the campaign via poll.The game will have various rules I'm still mulling over, such as who or what to target for attack with what each "turn." Armies will have set numbers that increase or decrease in various ways until one side reaches zero. There will be passive cards that provide various bonuses to either side depending on who controls them. Plus more.Here's the kicker: The greenskins were created to be a male-only race and therefore must take the females of other races to breed and increase their numbers, so one of their main objectives and main focus of the quest other than defeating the enemy armies is to capture slaves. They also have a very fast gestation period of only a month and grow to be a full-sized adult in a year. With a dark relic the orc warlord found this period is reduced further to only a month during the campaign, thus every two turns (a month) the number of greenskins increase based on the number of slaves they have. All this capturing and "number increasing" will be written in detail each time.I'm planning to keep it short and simple for the first attempt and I also want defeat to actually be possible.I'm perfectly fine with pastebinning the lewd parts, but if I have to do it on a (shitty) dead board like /trash/ I don't think I'd bother, there's just not enough people there for that to be fun. I don't know how strong the possible drama would be from attempting this would be either, which would likely draw moderator ire, I won't try if people think it's too unpleasant to be here either.
>>2638357What's the scale going to be?
>>2638369I'd suggest you run that on akun
>>2638377not enough mind control to be viable there
>>2638377Akun? You mean google?
>>2638374hard to predict that far into the futurebut around a mid/high level D&D campaign should be reasonable to assume
>>2638369I should also mention that this is war, so men will just straight up get killed a lot, though I won't be detailing that too deeply.
>>2638369What you're trying to do is in essence mix a civ game with a rape sim. Trust me, it'll get old really fast. There's someone who could pull it off extremely well (MZion) but for everyone else it'll disintigrate into mindless grind (hyuk, hyuk, hyuk!) within 3 threads.In other words: The idea is fundamentally unsuited for this medium.>>2638317>>2638311FQ's licentious updates got Oxicleaned several times, actually.>>2638181How would you define dark fantasy? What about high fantasy?
>>2638369>Orc rape questThat's some bargin bin trash right there man and it seems like you're making the smut the main selling point.My advice is to go jerk off then revise your premise. A less horny head might help here.
>>2638454You do realize jerking off kills motivation not just the sex drive right?
>>2638439It's less civ and more just basic numbers and cards, nothing too fancy, there's not going to be base-building or anything like that. I plan to keep it simple and short.For example: Farmland card, replenishes X number losses for allied forces every turn. Players can use a turn to burn it to the ground and negate the effects (and acquire a few farmers wives and daughters in the process).I want to give it a try anyway, worst that happens is it will fail. My main concern is if it does work out and then a mod comes along and deletes it it will definitely be a big waste of time.
>>2638468They probably will.>>2638459That's the joek.
>>2638454The smut one is the main selling points. The idea started off as just a simple story I was writing but while reading quests and certain doujins I thought it would be something different and interesting to try.
>>2638501Trust me. It isn't different or interesting.But you do you.
>>2638439Oh boy...I'll do the easier one first>High FantasyFor me at least it's a setting where magick is abundant, where mages and magick users are not a rarity but relatively commonplace.It also has a wide variety of fantastical races like goblins, kobolds etc. in it.It's also the setting where one can get creative.So...Low fantasy = Game of ThronesHigh Fantasy = D&DNow...>Dark fantasyNow please keep in mind I'm not talking about full grimdark.So...Dark fantasy is the one that doesn't pull any punches.Almost anything goes.Over all I'm aiming for a slightly less dark Berserk.
Oh god I've to run a quest in three hours and I didn't get a wink of sleep despite trying to sleep for three hoursplease advise
>>2638604are you anxious anon? succumb to the curse and delay! or act like an alpha QM and power through
>>2638609No, I'm not anxious. I'm worried I might fall asleep or just not focus or be constantly sweating and shitting myself in ways that even if I were to write the quest from my phone in a hot bath would I ever be comfortableNow this kind of pants-shitting panic is one of the subject matters of my story but it is so because it's not enjoyable and worrisome
>>2638604It's called abusing coffee anon.Brew several batches if you have to.You'll only have to worry about the consequences tomorrow when you shit out your innards
>>2638624man, treat it like an RPG, if you are not having fun don't do it
Civfags lurking in /qtg/, we've reformed our new Civ homeland. https://discord.gg/6pSRdJz is our new invite.
>>2638646Iron, a Tief's Quest, on Akun. It's about an autistic goat girl and her tard wrangler adventuring through a frozen wasteland of other goats. Also murder.
>>2638682>akunAh ok, do whatever you want. The quest sounds neat.
Is writemonkey still the go-to-word processor for someone without Word?
>>2638724openoffice, last i checked it was still free
Hey /qst/anon's, got a question for you. Just spent 3.5 weeks innawoods learning how boat in all kinds of conditions with no internet and spreading 1.2Gb of phone data over 14 days. Returning back to civilisation in 4 days, and I was debating on if I should restart 'Into The Wilderness Quest', even though thread 2 vanished into the mists, or to kick off a new quest about being in a mid fantasy trade caravan? I've saved my posts from the first quest' s missing second thread like an obsessive hoarder and can re-upload them into a pastebin when I'm back home, but is it worth the effort?>inb4 Why aren't you updating now shitbird?To get this connection, which is roughly one step above dial-up, I had to walk 3km to a bar. I don't feel like trying to update via phone, with no decent spell-checking, while getting increasingly hammered.
>>2618233So hey QMs, what do you put in your tags when you archive your quest? aside from quest name of course
>>2639488I still put in Collective Game into my tags.
>>2639488As a player I like to see Quest name, QM name and if the quest is set in a pre-existing setting the name of the setting
>>2637613You fucking retarded or are you trying to be this stupid? The thing that gets anons in the door isn't the initial choice. It's the management. You can argue all you want but you're still wrong if you think the only reason anons go into a civ thread is to choose a race and be like "oh boy I love choosing a race because that's the most enjoyable form of pure fucking ecstasy." and then when they found out they stumbled into something that doesn't involve a single fucking choice. Unless you're a complete fucking dunce you will understand that the "Initial appeal" isn't some throwaway choice to waste time voting on something because you're too fucking lazy to choose it yourself. So that said let's address your fuck ass argument.>The "race choice" is the stripping in this analogy.Oh yeah, the choice is the main appeal to playing a fucking civ game, not the management. That itself is the reason of your flawed logic when understanding why anyone plays a civ game. If the Tits were indeed just the fucking race choice then no one would fucking play Civ games past the first three votes. Considering the catalouge it looks like you're probably the person who keeps spamming civ threads for no reason other than that "initial appeal" you're so fucking fond of.>INITIAL appeal. Anything else anon? is that you're entire slob of a fucking argument is that "muh initial appeal iz a fukin single choise">I say you've been to the wrong civ threads.Seems to me you've never even played a civ thread in your life much less understand why anyone even goes into one. Fuck offLurk more you fucking imbecile.
Don't you just hate it when you finish an update just as someone votes things back into a tie?
>>2639730Should have called it if it was that contentious
>>2639738should start doing that
>>2639724Anon you just spent a large post bitching autistically in order to agree with everything he just said.Are you on the spectrum?
>>2639748Don't change IDs, anon.
>>2639755Unfortunately for you, I am not that anon. I am this anon >>2633935 >>2634454But you have answered my question regardless.
>>2618233What would be the plot of the quest where you owe a cyberpunk fantasy noir bar?
>>2639836>>2639840A New Mutant Quest has updated.
>>2639488Dark, fantasy, DrawQuest, Mild Lewdness, Graphic Violence, MySojourn
>>2639525>quests in a pre-existing setting
I always wanted a vampire questI don't know what kind but every single one I've read never hit the mark for me
Any news on MSPQ?What was the last thing Wong said about it?
Fuck Me, My Daughter's A Magical Girl! quest has somehow gotten a third thread: >>2639338I'm just advertising.
>>2639918that title already has my sides
>>2639943I came up with the idea when I was blackout drunk.By the time I'd sobered up a bit, I was knee-deep in QM-ing a quest thread.
>>2639880The last thing he said was the he was going on hiatus.
>>2639993Did he said when is was going to come back?Wasn't there something about he being sick during the spring or something?
>>2640027He usually gets sick throughout spring, but he never exactly said when he was coming back. I'm sure he'll come back, but no idea when or how long it'll be.
>>2640029It has been too long, now I'm already questioning if he will ever come back.Man... this is depressing... But it has been 4 months already.
>>2640053He put a lot of time into the quest, I'm sure he'll come back eventually.
>>2639724Ignoring the rest of your idiocy:>implying I think the choice is the main appeal to playing a fucking civ game, not the management.Main appeal =/= INITIAL appealDo you not understand this concept?The INITIAL appeal of a wrapped present is the lovely wrapping, unwrapping it, and unveiling the MAIN appeal: the actual present.Get it?If the race choice is completely irrelevant, why do all civ threads start with it?Do you think they do it just to piss you off?>>2639748>Anon you just spent a large post bitching autistically in order to agree with everything he just said.This.
>>2639866Kae's ass is more than mild lewdness.
>>2640175>>2639866I really hope she doesn't die.
>>2639488Quest name, Collective game. That's it.
>>2640108I hope you're right anon.It would be too sad for things to end at this point.
>tfw so incredibly slow writing my quest with over an hour between meager updatesI lost my ability to do my job expediently but I didn't lose my duty to see it through
>>2639488Sarcastic descriptors of what happens or doesn't happen in the thread. Some facetious others not. "Shitty Romance" is my favorite.
Anyone up for weirdness about zombies and rain?Continuing >>2635672
>>2638724Google Docs isn't bad.
>>2639488Holy shit, that GIF is adorable.
>>2639488Quest name is all that's really necessary. Collective game isn't needed anymore since we're on "Collective Games: The Board", but I still add it because old habits die hard. QM name should only really go in if you plan on running multiple quests and want a way for possible fans to read your earlier work.If you want to go further than that you could also add the genre, setting, and maybe the tone. Anything more is either overkill or it belongs in the description.
>>2639488Aside from the name, I put the common quest abbreviation, the MC’s name, my QM name, and the setting name. Covers most anything someone searching the quest without remembering the quest’s name would type in the search to find it.
>>2635672this is running right now and I found it interesting, I have to go to bed now but I decided to post it here to give QM more players, hope you guys like it
My country ip range ban is over. fuck you Barney fag.>player question.Command and conquer. Could be large scale fights like the games or small group trying to survive the crapsack world.Tactics ogre. Story will never be finished, interesting world.
>>2641890>Tactics Ogrehow would that work? The game mechanics are too crunchy to work for the number of people that are involved in each fight.
>>2641897>please roll 500d100.Maybe like a civ? Have the mc and party do the "big" stuff? Simplify it?
>>2641890>Command and conquer. Could be large scale fights like the games or small group trying to survive the crapsack world.This gives me the urge to play Command & Conquer: Zero Hour now. I don't think I've seen a modern-esque strategy quest yet. >>2641905That would work best.
>>2641905But would it really be Tactics Ogre at that point?
>>2641890Who is Barneyfag?
>>2642075My guess is someone who got IP range banned for posting something Barney related.The real question here is, WHO WAS PHONE?
>>2642085>BarneyIs this a new meme?
>>2642075Apparently:>Barneyfag is an absolute lunatic who trolls the boards looking for any trace of pony so he can screech autistically at whoever posted it, generally much to the amusement of everyone else. AFAIK, his reasoning is that he was in special ed and they made him watch Barney the Dinosaur, and MLP reminds him of that so it legitimately triggers him into fits of apoplectic rage>Actually, he makes the threads himself and then switches IPs to start complaining about them. Apparently he forgot to switch IPs once and got caught samefagging due to poster count.Saw him post once.Made the original "BBEG ugh" anon seem sane.
>>2642120And entire regions get banned from posting as a result? Does it usually affect the same countries or are his IP changes random?
>>2642128Collateral damage anon, that why they dropped the A bombs, some thousands suffer to stop a war/shitpost
>>2642120>he makes the threads himselfno he doesn't.
>when I have more unique IPs then my rivals quest this cycleI guess he couldn't stand the test of time, fanfics only get you so far boy.
Quick question:How do I tournaments?Has anyone attempted to write a proper fighting championship?
>>2642128>>2642166I wouldn't know.
>>2642316Peasant Lord Quest just did...One swordfight took 4 days.Heh.
>>2642332That sounds like fun... but maybe a bit too long for my liking.Was it literally two peasants swinging swords at each other or did it have some sort of magical elements to it?
>>2642346It was mundane, yeah. We might've been magically influenced to love someone, but that wasn't directly relating to the fight.
>>2642087The Simpsons in general are a meme, so I would think so. Don't quote me, though, because I haven't seen any images of Barney floating around; I'm just making assumptions.
>>2642346It was two lords and the fate of everything, up to and including the biological clock of Marisa Tomei from My Cousin Vinny, was hanging in the balance so it was compelling.But yeah, everyone agreed the rules needed reworking.
>>2642136It would be nice if that actually stopped shitposting. It really is only a delay, and is a huge inconvenience for the innocent.
Demonologist Quest resumes.>>2642610>>2642610>>2642610Summon demons for fun and profit, get sassed by a talking crow, deal with angry fish people, and try not to get broken on a wheel.
Do Your Best quest is running again, continuing the thread. It's got really good art and good characters and a plot, we need more voters, please vote!>>2642866>>2642866>>2642866
>>2642965A New Mutant Quest has updated.
>>2642166>>2642330Barney fag most likely starts his own threads to signpost in. Be glad he has not posted in qst.>>2642055I mean managing every unit by yourself is out of the question.
>>2642412The fucking dinosaur.Not Rubble.Not Gumble.Not Fife.
>>2643032But what makes it Tactics Ogre and not, say, a civ game?
What happened to 'I Can't Understand what my Isekai is Saying!'? Did it died after the whole narnia stuff?Also the houseki no kuni quest, that was the same guy, right? Dead too?
>>2643377AyyYeah the quest kind of slowed down after that, I tried to reel it back in and get back to the good stuff but at that point it was just a bit difficult to get information out. I've been rethinking how the whole thing should go, and sometime soon I'm going to start it fresh with a new idea. I'm putting together a complete (ish) dictionary for the language, and have been building a font as well.Gembutts is actually almost ready to come back, I needed to take a break to rediscover what it was about the series that initially brought on so much inspiration, it seemed like it would've been unfair to let it keep going until any creative merit it had was drained. My guess is around a week and a half or two weeks, just to let this quarter of school finish up and to sync up with the monthly serializations again.Sorry you got lost in the crowd, I've tried to let as many people know about what was going on with both as I could, but I had wrongfully assumed the readership to be limited to a couple discord servers I was in.Pic related is a preview of the font, it's coming along quite well although I'm still learning how to put together ligatures. "Nair seket no?" -> "Is this a bull cock?"
>>2643443>Sorry you got lost in the crowd, I've tried to let as many people know about what was going on with both as I could, but I had wrongfully assumed the readership to be limited to a couple discord servers I was in.It is always discord this discord that nowadays.>Pic related is a preview of the font, it's coming along quite well although I'm still learning how to put together ligatures.Your dedication is noteworthy, even if the actual execution can be lacking.
>>2618233>>QM Question:>Does player discussion in your quest impact the future events you haven't written yet? As in will you change or add something based on your anons shooting the shit and coming up with ideas.It depends on the quest and how much effort/worldbuilding has gone into a setting. If the voters shape things too much, you don't have a "live" world that feels real. But I do add 'meta' shit based on discussion, so yes?>>Player Question:>What is a quest you hope to see in the future? (Genre and series included within context)Hmm. Pirate shit. Toku/henshin hero shit (I know we have two or three right now but I mean more obviously).>>Player Question 2: Electric Boogaloo>Do you have a 11/10 moment in a quest you remember fondly? Tell us.Not at all.>>Special lurker question: >When was the last time you voted in a quest? Was it a crucial vote? You should probably vote more. Your QM will appreciate it.A few seconds ago.
Also, what mod(s) thought it was a good idea to have posts be undeleteable? Jeez.
>>2643606Posts are deletable, though.
>>2643614From what I've seen it's only if you delete it in the first few minutes.
>>2643626That's like that everywhere though
>/qtg/ was mad 9 days ago>only 400 replysIs the /qtg/ an obsolete old boys club? If so what kind of meta thread should replace it?
>>2644529/qst/ in general is an obsolete old boy's club.
Continuing the Hunter Exam in Hunter X Hunter quest.>>2644534>>2644534Come on and join!
Anyone know a good place to find RP partners for discord?
>>2644617e621 forums, off topic section.
>>2644617What KIND of RP?
>>2644993>>2644993>>2644993Spooky Girl Quest continues.Could this guy you're on a date with be Baphomet? The Black, Forbidden God of the Templars?
>>2643606>Quarterly reminder that this was the mindset /qst/mod had when this board was founded>QM Question:Yes. I loved nothing more then to see players speculate and talk which would spark potential long term ideas for events and story. I tried to harness this constructively by providing opportunities for writein solutions. Best part is when you learn something new and anons can have a wide ranger of experience. Learned all about fire traps on castle walls and their history in the West from one anon who got everyone to vote for installing them on the party fort.>Player Question:A gamey strategic one, either modern or sci-fi. >Player Question 2: Electric BoogalooThere was a civ quest. We were automaton. There was one robot that always got bad rolls. Always. Needless to say, he was bullied relentlessly. So much so I have over 14 pics a drawfag did of him getting bullied. Disc robo's best robo's.
>>2645489>>2645492A New Mutant Quest has updated.
>>2618365Where do you post your stuff now? I looked up your tumbler and it hasnt been updated in like a year
>>2645864twitter.com/cegremo_hq but I don't post much art these days.
>>2646899>>2646901A New Mutant Quest has updated.
Demonologist Quest resumes.>>2642610>>2642610>>2642610Summon demons for fun and profit, search ancient tunnels for a thief, deal with a snooty aristocratic demon who doesn't want to ruin his nice clothes, and try not to get broken on a wheel.
>halfway through writing an update>find a moment to add something I wanted to so the whole direction of the writing gets changed>update ends up taking more than half the dayFuck that was hard work
>>2647303If you like slime, and you like time, then look no further!
How long should I, as a quest maker, keep making threads if I only have 2-5 people responding most of the time?
>>2647543As long as you like.If 2-5 people is enough for you, keep on, but otherwise, don't.
>>2647545At what point fo I have to come to terms with the fact that I will never have more than 2-5 players?
>>2630892JQOP likes a certain type of MC that's very Eastwood-ish.
>>2647549given the length of /qst/'s threads, i'd say thread ~4 or so is a good time to realize your audience will never widen.
>>2647549That's entirely your preference. Some QM's would be ecstatic with 2-5 players and run indefinitely if they maintained that. Some even less. If you're not satisfied though or want more, then it may be better to call if quits if you want to try again.
>>2647549Second or third thread.
>>2647549If you're not enough without more (You)s, you'll never be enough with them.
>>2647543God, I wish I had 2-5 players.
>>2647742You only run for 1 person?That's rough, my dude
After a long break,An update on the Paladin of Avalon is up!https://fiction.live/stories/The-Paladin-of-Avalon/-JRvxJl3loGBg9Bo64XE/32-Traitor-s-Mask/u69XfGkq6rBjfqEzNThey offered no riddles to solve
Not counting Moloch's stuff, Lamplighter and HMQ, what are a few quests with really exceptional writing?
>>2647931Valen Quest(I hope it didn't die)
>>2647931No one will agree with me on it but I think MSPQ had great writing when it came to characters and their relationships.
>>2647993Mecha Space Pirate Quest
>>2647931Wasnt this asked last thread AND while there was a "quest recommendation thread" hanging around the catalog?
>>2648004People are dumb and don't read, go figure.
This thread won't even hit 500 replys
>>2648499I suppose not
>>2648499Try asking an interesting question to start an interesting discussion, instead of whining uselessly.
>>2648622>implying you have anything interesting to say
What do you think makes a satisfying conclusion to a quest? The QM admitting they give up? The protagonist(s) dying? Getting the waifu? The friends you made along the way?
>>2648856Quality resolution of the overarching plotline of the quest while also tying up any subplots raised along the way.
>>2648499>Anons aren't saying enough>>2648684>Anons have nothing interesting to saySo, what?You want more uninteresting posts?If you're going to shitpost, do it with a modicum of consistency and sense.
>>2648743Super Robot Wars Quest is up! We're still in chargen, even though it won't be as intensive as people expect it to be.
>>2648856Main plot getting a resolution.You know, like most stories in every other medium.
>>2648927Is it that much of a dealbreaker?
>>2648952For me, yes.
>>2648952No. It's a meme.
>>2648906A bit late for me but WOOHOO.
>>2649531>>2649531>>2649531Spooky Girl Quest continues. Supernatural bullshit collides with high school relationship bullshit.
>>2648856easy, dropping the quest without saying anything.
>>2647993>>2647995MSPQ is great in many levels, including writting.Just ignore the shitposting and in-fighting between players.
>>2647931Elder Loli Quest.
>>2649829The weirdest thing about the playerbase was how it was almost completely split between those who wanted to destroy Avalon and those who wanted to save them.
>>2649983A New Mutant Quest has updated.
Chargen is so lame
>>2648952Personally I won't read any further on a quest with a female lead once I see that it has one.
>>2650159ew a thotget the spray
>Go to Rec thread >Two of the quests recommended both go on hiatus/die What did /qst/ mean by this
>>2649900What? I think there was just brazil, avalonanon, solaire and maybe one or two mor guys that were okay with avalon. Mostly of the rest were just neutral, with a relevant number of "just kill them all" followers of Thunder.To be fair, all of the avalonians problems and the problems people had with them were directly or indirectly caused by the Greenlady, heck, even the war only began because they didn't wanted to let the jovians execute her. It's not like the avalonians were a bunch of murderhobos or something, in that regard the martian and jovians were way worse with their expansionism and corrupted officers.
>>2650178Kae is not for bullying.Kae is for hugs and fugs.
>>2650381At the end of the day the Avalonians are siding with a woman who helped kill 2/3rds of humanity.
>>2650387Don't worry anon, the SSL will kill another 2 thirds to make sure that she doesn't has the chance to do it herself.Kek, I miss MSPQ
New Civ thread here. Looking for votes.(https://fiction.live/stories/Hex-Civ-Thread/juckE37LjutQDjGAN)
>>2650404Whatever it takes to burn those veggies.
>>2650417>tfw jovian supporters actually believe that killing another 2/3rds of humanity is acceptable to kill a greenman jobber who has a crush on a human.
>>2650422>crush on a human.She's just bidding her time anon why else do you think she made an army of the Avalonians.
>>2650429Man, we don't have any mean of knowing what she if after, my bet is that she is just going "Oh, the things I have done... So now I have to lead humanity to a new era of prosperity and yadda yadda need to break some eggs to do an omelett"She doesn't even properly have an army, the KINGDOM OF AVALON as an army, she is just the superhuman that gives them wise advice and SUPER-TECHNOLOGY, why the hell would they give up on her because of what she may have done in the war? Is that going to fix something? Okay, she might be a fanatic who just wants to keep forcing her head against a wall until it breaks... But lets be honest here, the greenman are all dead, they utterly failed, and humanity never even got exactly why they did what they did, they just assumed that they done that "because of evulz and stuff"... They probably just wanted to force humanity into a new era of perfection and yadda yadda, and now there is no hope, the galaxy was broken to pieces and they just had to face their doom of their values.Is it possible for the LAST greenman alive to be a spoilered bitch who doesn't learns from her mistakes and still thinks she can force humanity into things? Yes. Is it the probable reaction of a SUPERHUMAN MIND WITH EONS OF LEARNING AND EXPERIENCE? No....Also, we just need to kill her, pink haired bitch and maybe a third of the paladins and the war would be over. Unless the SSL just wants to keep fighting them to have an excuse for people to join their new CUSS.
>>2650442No they wanted to kill humanity because they kept fucking up the environment and if left alone would keep fucking up everything until no world was left habitable.
>>2648927>>2648956>being turned off by a female lead and not the fact that it's fanfiction
>>2650515Its SRW it can be literally anything as long as he ties together all the pilots.
Hey guys, skirmishes are starting to open up again. Everwinter company, Gyrocite, and world tree! Come join and fight goblins or hijack a train! :D
>>2650482Who said that? The Jovians? That one mad guy in Quil'r? We know they were hellbent who cleasing humanity, but in no moment we got confirmation that they wanted to kill EVERYONE. Thye even have cultists and stuff, those guys were probably the one they were keeping for "the new era" or something.But it still doesn't defeat my point, we have no evidences that GL is still following the plan.
>>2650601Yeah those cultists looked great didn't they, can't see why anybody wouldn't want to driven mad by fungus growing in them.
>>2650606Yeah, all those cultists that we have never seen looked great.Man, you're just changing the goalpost. What the cultists looked like, felt, planned, did, or ended like doesn't even matter to the disscussion. I was never saying that the greenman were right, heck, nobody was right, the martians killed EVERYONE to just avoid the infection spreading, no matter if they were sure about them being infected or not.The thing I'm asking is, is it probable that the Lady still plans to continue with the old plan? after the huge failure it was? While being a superhuman with an inteligence far ahead from us?But are you worried about what she will actually do or with revenge? If we are after revenge and punishment then we should begin here in the solar system, I'm sure there are still plenty of people around who killed huge amounts of innocents for tactical advantage.Oh, but wait, now they're very important people that contribute heavily to current level of civilization, aren't they?... Are the solars any different from the avalonians?
>>2650668Very. The solars haven't been living on a planet with a Greenman that they constantly visit and tours around the planet. Whoses to say she could have spored the entire damn planet.
>Quest has plot holes and inconsistencies in loreIs this a dealbreaker or is it acceptable because of the haphazard nature of these things?
>>2650674The martians have fucking hakim around, whoses to say he could have planted bombs on the entire damn planet, JUST IN CASE he needs to explode some - or all - of them.
>>2650675It is frustrating, but I wouldn't drop a quest over it. The QM should have a main idea of where the plot is headed, have important lore and characters planned ahead of time.Failing that, if the QM is simply winging everything, it's still up to them to go through their thread after the session and compile relevant information/characters, and piece together or plan out possible paths. It sounds autistic, but it can help keep things consistent.
>>2650675Just patch the holes with bullshit anon.
I've been thinking of doing a Raccoon City Quest since the remake of Resident Evil 2 was announced. Would start in game time-wise (and these are the canon dates due to information found in the games) on September 27th, When the third Resident Evil game starts and end on the 30th when Leon, Claire, and Sherry flee the city. The PC though will not encounter the characters from the games since I'd like it to stand alone. You might find your self in an area where they have been or just missed them by a couple of minutes.
>>2638253>civ general is impossibleWe do have a Civ discord though. I suggest you join it https://discord.gg/6pSRdJz
>>2650738>it's another "hey I'm excited about this thing, I should make a quest about it" quest
>>2647931Hive Queen Quest was great, until QD went quiet. Death Among the Stars has been pretty good as well, though it’s slowed down a lot at this point.
>>2650869>>2650869Valkyria Chronicles Pacific Theatre is back after a respite. The promised battleship heist is well under way.
>>2650675>Quest has plot holes and inconsistencies in loreThis is rarely a problem for me as a player or a QM.1st: Make certain the QM is aware of it.Sometimes they use the wrong proper name, cite the wrong fact, or just plain forget something and it can fixed with a quick "Oh, I meant X not Y."QMs are human and there is no edit function.2nd: Any QM, or GM, worth their salt can respond to a major inconsistency being pointed out by replying something like ”That does seem odd, doesn't it?" or "What do you think that could mean?”Inconsistencies remain mysteries until confirmed mistakes.3rd: Not every apparent error is really an inconsistency.Professor Snape seemed to behave inconsistently until you learn the full truth.4th: If the QM does screw up, they can always spin a narrative to explain it all.
>>2651201This one has the right of it.
>>2650675It's fine, geez.There was one plot hole/inconsistency that I found that was simply met with: Oh. huh. Let's just retcon that. AND IT'S TOTALLY FINE.Trying too hard to explain away as some super twist can cripple the original plan you had going forward, no shame in admitting a mistake or two on your way to the current flow.
>>2648743Super Robot Wars Quest, resuming.
>>2650675a wizard did it
>>2651393ThisNobody's quest is perfect.The mixing up of proper names I mentioned was from the first thread of a solid, well done quest I checked out once.They're still going strong to my knowledge.Fear of making mistakes won't prevent making mistakes. Nothing will.Fear of screwing up your quest won't prevent screwing up your quest in some way. Nothing will.Accept failure as part of the process, just as most players do.Will some asshole players expect perfection anyway? Maybe, but they're assholes. Who gives a shit?Will some players make fun of you for fucking up? This is 4chan. You bet your ass they will. And that's fine.
>>2651730A New Mutant Quest has updated.
>>2651540Yeah, I've fucked up a few times. Still trying to place the chronology of the past.
Demonologist Quest resumes, now with 50% more fish.>>2642610>>2642610>>2642610Summon demons for fun and profit, discover a secretive cabal that may or may not be trying something that only Hell Itself can pull off, negotiate with fish to save a town, and try not to get broken on a wheel.
>>2651737Helps having a setting where a group has been "gifted youngsters" for decades.
Weird post-apocalypse zombie unlife updates!>>2635672>>2635672
Bladebound Retainer resumes, in spite of computer troubles and captcha shenanigans.>>2652041>>2652041>>2652041
Question for everyone:Firstly, would a quest where you are the GM of a TTRPG (abstractly DND, etc) group interest anyone? Meaning, You the players have to make sure that the session goes well both narratively as well as monitoring the enjoyment levels of the players and their PCs.And secondly, how would you as a player want to interact with/guide this sort of quest?
>>2653567>>2653567>>2653567The heat goes on. Some dark fantasy fun.
>>2653489I wouldn't think so, but that QM Quest was fun.
>>2653847Who is this post meant to be directed to? The guys who don't like Femc?Is it a reply to the wrong thread?I don't see anyone here stating there's a conspiracy to make traditional games politically correct.
>>2653994Wars of the Free: Chapter 1 is live
Let this be our final battle for the age old question...https://strawpoll.com/pye5he32Fem Mc or male Mc?
>>2654097Where is the 'It doesn't fucking matter as long as they are a good character' option?
>>2654105That's called not voting
>>2654105>>2654113To easy, what's the point of even having a poll if we're all going to be reasonable people?
>>2654097*if you don't vote in this poll your favourite QM will drop his quest without saying anything and never return tonight
What are some good mecha quests? I just tried reading space pirate but it starts so slow and uninteresting that I gave up.
>>2654097Femc = waifu trashDebate me.
>>2654693Male Mc == harem quest
>>2654693Only if it you want it to be.
I am having trouble deciding on a time period for a harry potter quest, I want it to be set on the early 20th century but there isn't a lot going on in terms of enemies and stuff like that.I dunno, what do you anons think?
>>2654693If your reasoning is that any femc is going to be waifued, and will therefore become waifu trash, I would argue that if anons are that consistent with their desperate waifuing, those same anons will waifu anything.Given the utter absence of females to waifu, they will waifu a Hot Pocket, a sword, or an ideology.If you are suggesting that it is impossible to imagine a female protagonist without her being intended as a waifu, I think you're on the wrong board.
>>2654828I think if you can't find or make enemies, you haven't been on 4chan long enough.
>>2654878I am trying to keep it as lore friendly as possible
>>2654828You know (((who))) must must be defeated.>>2654886Also fuck the lore, we alt history now.
>>2654888hmmm... welp fuck it.Also this quest is not gonna be ''wow a chocolate frog! Oh! its a alive! wow!" Its gonna be dark and fuck magic, we smith & wesson
>>2654828Just make something up. Not every fight against an evil wizard was big enough to hit the history books, and even if you wanted to do something big you can just do what every other fanfic writer does and make canon your bitch.
>>2654886If you want to make a lore-friendly story with enemies in a setting without a lot of enemies, then you need to make the story small-scale.Not every conflict needs to hang the magical world in the balance. All you really need is one rogue wizard managing to avoid the authorities for your main characters to encounter. That's a small blip in the settings lore, all things considered.
>>2654916>>2654912the thing is the mc would be evil in this case, he hates wizards which is explained either early on or later on.
>>2654928He hates Wizards.Who could possibly be his enemies?Maybe, I don't know, all wizards?
>>2654947fair point, I meant as specific character but nevermind I just need to write some notes now
>>2654961Just make him a wizard that hates (((wizards)))
>>2654961Maybe the enemy is a specific wizard who sparked this hatred of wizardkind. Maybe the MC has already done some stuff against the wizards and the enemy is an auror or some shit who was sent to track him down.You have a decent starting point. All you need to do is build.
>>2654967>>2654976well I am giving it a twist, he is a muggle that realizes the existence of wizards and manages to avoid getting mind wiped
>>2654992a wizard that just hates other wizards just dont have enough edge but enough said I need to write a lot
>>2654996How about:"I died and was resurrected as the dark lord Voldemort who has regenerated himself again and is secretly enrolled in hogwarts in order to murder harry potters granddaughter but she is actually really cute and a bully???"send me the royalties when it gets made into a movie
Ah, waking up to a thread sage. Very least, I can take a break now that its over along with finals. May even revise my character sheets again.
Pickin' up from yesterday, more zombie unlife unfolds.>>2635672>>2635672
>>2653662Tell me about this? I only vaguely remember what you're referring to..
i have so many drawquest ideas but i feel like im too incompetent to start any of them and do them any justice
>>2655652>i feel like im too incompetent to start any of themStart them anyways.
>>2655475First chapter of Meldric Adventurers Quest starting here.GraveQMs new quest while Death Among the Stars Quest is on a short hiatus.
>>2655652Remember; it's impossible to disappoint anyone so long as you never try. Just stop before you've become anything to anybody and you're technically a net good, see? Keep up the good work anon!
>>2655652Start it faget, that's what I did.
>>2654693Just because a character flirts with the MC, doesn't mean the MC has to date them. Especially as a female, when realistically they have the power to turn down suitors. Sure, men choose to ask a woman out, but ultimately the woman is the one who accepts or turns him down. Use that power, turn down the husbando, and get shit done in a cool manner like a proper protag.
>>2655652Are you me? I have a bunch of concepts swarming around my mind, and no time to really outline any of them.
>>2656061Take all your ideas and smuush them together.
>>2655559Literally what it says on the tin.A drawquest following an mc that's a QM struggling to make a successful quest.It was meta-licious!
>>2653662>>2655559>>2656336Fuck.It was "Quest Quest".It was a bitch to find.https://archived.moe/qst/thread/2392785/#2395496
>>2656421Ahahahaha the sojourner guy made this? good shit
>>2655652Incompetence is par for the course when it comes to starting a quest. You learn it by doing. Just decide what you want to do and run it.
>>2658234Princess Principal Mercenary-Gentleman #9Where you, Henry Adams, Browning journey in the industrial AU 1901 London and does whatever the hell you can do to make some money. And anime.
>>2657481>>2656336Thank ya, I do my best.
What do you prefer in your fantasy settings; humans only or other races as well?
>>2660043Other races that aren't copy and pasted from Tolkien or whatever your source of favorite elf sluts is
>>2660075What if it's furry races that are hostile to humans?
>>2660081On what scale of furry are they? In a sliding scale of Skaven to. EQ Ratonga to tgchan's varieties of "Rat People" (disambiguation). There are more specific examples from tgchan that do actually have depth, but I'd rather keep this simple.The differences should be fairly obvious, as there's very clear intent in the purpose of a race when looked at it in a broad terms. People can generally tell or get a feeling based on what you're putting out or saying about the race. Simplifying it by a magnitude or two, Skaven are portrayed as a terrible living curse. tgchan variety rats are there for sexy/adorable rodent traits because furry.If your monster people are hostile to humans they should have a good reason to be that way, other than that how much I'd prefer a race depends on how they're portrayed and what the DM is getting across with them, what part of the setting they occupy, the functional (or nearly) goals of their society, and what sort of culture their history and/or magic has built for them.In essence, it depends.
Running a space shipgirl quest later at the end of this week
READ MY QUESTMy Older Brother Can't Be This Hard To Seduce Quest>>2658793>what is is about?A younger sister trying to get her brother to fall in love with her.>why should you read it?The poor MC has failed for years to get her brother to see her as a woman. Only you can help her make her dream come true.>wow this sounds like a quality quest when do you run it?Whenever I feel like idk
>>2660043>What do you prefer in your fantasy settings; humans only or other races as well?>>2660075>Other races that aren't copy and pasted from XThisI want fantasy races, but implemented well.Most dwarves, for example, are dwarves being dwarves because dwarves.They need to feel organic to the setting and not there because the creator wanted dwarves, elves, and erotically charged moth people.>>2660081>What if it's furry races that are hostile to humans?I personally don't reee at furry.There's been too many cool characters that would count.Basically, >>2660114This.The question reminded me of one case that cemented a red flag for me:Any mention of the specifics of sexual reproduction or gestation in a homebrewed race is always a huge red flag.Pretty much any mention of reproduction other than Xenomorph analogs or spores is a red flag.
>>2660244>Any mention of the specifics of sexual reproduction or gestation in a homebrewed race is always a huge red flag.Fertility and how this impact demographics should be ok, right? As in the classic "elves rarely reproduce but there is always more orcs" but with other races.